Better On A Bagel

Port Jefferson Sta, United States

3.8

6 reviews

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 631-473-5858
Address:
4960 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Sta, NY, 11776
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
1 miPort Jefferson
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Today

Today –
Local time (Port Jefferson Sta) 3:12 AM Sunday, June 1, 2025

Business hours

Monday –
Tuesday –
Wednesday –
Thursday –
Friday –
Saturday –
Sunday –

Vicinity

Browse nearby places:
70
ft
Carmine’s
4950 Nesconset Hwy
110
ft
Mavis Discount Tire
4915 Nesconset Hwy
270
ft
Hertz Rent A Car
4869 Nesconset Highway
300
ft
Tutti Frutti
5110 Nesconset Hey
520
ft
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
5120 Nesconset Hwy
540
ft
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
Nesconset Shopping Center 5120 Nesconset Hwy

6 reviews of Better On A Bagel

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Long Island, NY
Great bagels, good people, good service. Coffe is not the best. Very good egg sandwiches. If you like soft chewy bagels (like me) then this is the place. Definately the best bagels in Port Jefferson. Trust me, I’ve been to all of the others.
Place rating: 5
Shoreham, NY
This is a good bagel place and is better than most other bagel places in the area. The bagels are dark, crispy and covered with lots of toppings. There is ample seating and the staff is very friendly. They also have the *commuter special* which inclues free coffee with some purchases.
Place rating: 1
East Moriches, NY
This is probably the worst egg sandwich I’ve ever had. The bagel is terrible, and pretty stale, but the taste is just off. Almost as if there were a «chemical» flavor to it. I’m assuming this is the «medicine» taste another reviewer was mentioning.
Place rating: 2
Long Island, NY
What the what? I just bought a bagel here. They are tremendous, with no hole and the Everything bagel tasted like medicine.
The space is old and dirty looking
They only accept cash
I want to support any small business, Panera is across the street and competition must be tough. But the bagel was really really bad and cash only makes me wanna say pass on this place.
Place rating: 5
Miller Place, NY
My favorite bagels. I’ve had many LI bagels and I always want to return to Better on a Bagel. My family has been getting bagels from this place for probably 20 years, or however long its been open. They are perfectly soft and chewy with excellent flavor. The best!
Place rating: 5
East Setauket, NY
This is my favorite bagel place on the Island. I go when ever i can and the bagel’s are always great. Usually get either a breakfast special (2 eggs any way w/​bacon or sausage and cheese on roll or bagel) or an egg everything with scailon cream cheese. This place has never disapointed me and the owner is a really nice guy!