The Amazing Olive

Port Jefferson, United States

4.8

Closed now

11 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 631-509-4596
Website:
www.amazingolive.com
Address:
230 E Main St, Port Jefferson, NY, 11777
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
1 miPort Jefferson
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Street
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes

Today

Today 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Port Jefferson) 11:40 PM Wednesday, June 18, 2025

Business hours

Monday 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Tuesday 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Wednesday 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Thursday 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Friday 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Saturday 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Sunday 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

Description

Specialties

We are an olive oil and vinegar tasting bar, where you can taste our products and have them bottled fresh for you.

History

Established in 2013.

We discovered the concept of a tasting bar while on vacation. We then contacted the California Olive Oil Council and began to learn about quality extra virgin olive oils.

Meet the Business Owner

kandy M.

Business Owner

My husband Ralph and I are the owners of The Amazing Olive. Ralph and I along with our children and grandchildren run the business. My love for baking and cooking along with Ralphs knowledge of a healthy lifestyle are a perfect balance for the world of oils and vinegars.

Related places

Explore similar places:
4.6
mi
The Crushed Olive
133 Main St
5.4
mi
Athena Diamond Inc.
7 Flowerfield
5.8
mi
Spice Professors
5.8
mi
House of Spice
1228 Middle Country Rd

Vicinity

Near this location:
1
ft
Salon Dale
230 E Main St
1
ft
Jimi Vals Star Guitars Plus Incorporated
230 E Main St
40
ft
Pasta Pasta
234 E Main St
50
ft
Suffolk County National Bank
228 E Main St
100
ft
Home & Garden Co
234 Traders Cv
100
ft
Inspired By Life

11 reviews of The Amazing Olive

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Meriden, CT
We come here every year! The people are really nice and the tastings are great!!!
They are also by the Farmers Market once you get off the ferry. Sometimes the prices there are a little cheaper.
Also, be sure to download the BELLY app to score bonus points for each visit
Place rating: 5
Chelsea, MA
we found this amazing store while googling things to see and do while we were mid lsland this past w/​e. we couldn’t make it when we drove in, that would’ve made sense cause we had more time. on the rush to get in line for the return ferry, we ran off to find you. so glad we did. I came in looking for basil infused oil and found it and the mango pineapple vinegar (or was it something else?) OMG!!! we are planning for a return trip, just for the amazing olive. it was that good!!! we can’t wait to come back!!!
Place rating: 5
Suffolk County, NY
We came in while waiting for a table at a nearby restaurant. The staff member Steve was extremely helpful and friendly. The olive oil selection was great. I tried oils that I didn’t know existed. The prices were perfect. I will be back to refill my bottle.
Place rating: 4
Patchogue, NY
I’ve been meaning to come here for a while and finally checked it out. This is a cute little store off Main St.
They have the store split in half, with half being olive oils and have being balsamic vinegars. There are jars of bread placed throughout the store with sample cups so that you can help yourself to try any/​all of the varieties they have there.
I sampled a good amount of both oils and vinegars and ended up with a Habanero Citus olive oil and a Raspberry balsamic vinegar. Deeeeelicious!
The staff was super helpful and you just have to give them a heads up when you want to buy a bottle, and they fill it up for you right there. The bottles are a littleee expensive, but it is a specalty shop and it’d be rude to try everything without buying something.
Can’t wait for my next visit, and if you bring back the bottle to refill it’s $ 1 off!
Place rating: 5
New York, NY
Walking down the block we stumbled upon this place and entered in search of quality olive oil. They had a lot of selections to choose from, most of which was imported from Italy. Ralph was so nice he even gift wrapped the bottle for me. Italians love garlic, pasta, cannolis and olive oil so it should be a hit with my gfs dad. Check it out
Place rating: 4
Phoenix, AZ
I came in here last week with fam and friends and we had a pretty awesome time. We came during a tasting and had the opportunity to try some very rich and tasty oils and vinegars. We ended up buying several oils and vinegars, including on expresso infused oil, and another amazing tuscan balsamic vinegar. We also bought an adorable hand carved honey dipper. The Amazing Olive is a very clean, very cool place to stop by when in Port Jeff. There aren’t many places like it and the quality of the products here are top notch along with the service and attention the manager (s) offer visitors. I definitely recommend stopping here for some personal and gift shopping. Also, the prices are very reasonable.
Place rating: 5
New York, NY
I discovered this charming store on a recent trip to Port Jefferson. It is a beautifully appointed shop with an incredible selection of infused olive oils, balsamic vinegar and various bath and beauty products. Sampling is encouraged, as there are so many unusual choices (how else could you make a decision?). I tried the truffle infused balsamic vinegar, and it was love at first taste. I am now using it on pretty much everything I make. I adore small businesses that have truly first rate products, not to mention great customer service. The friendly gentleman who assisted us was never pushy, and at the same time was genuinely enthusiastic about the products. I intend to go back as soon as possible. What a great find!
Place rating: 5
Port Murray, NJ
Great selection of oils, balsamics, salts, peppers, etc.
We were in Port Jefferson and thought we’d wander around for a bit. The Amazing Olive is a block or two up from the harbor, but well worth a visit.
They had a number of interesting flavors that change from time to time. They also carry herbs, exotic salts, peppers, meat rubs, cheese boards, baskets, and crafts.
The owner is knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly.
Make sure you stop in when you’re in Port Jeff. You won’t be sorry.
Place rating: 5
Long Island, NY
I just stopped in my sons, I’ve been meaning to come here for a while now.
Who doesn’t like Olive Oil? Mmmmm… Wanna do something good for your body? Stop using butter on bread. Instead buy a good Olive Oil, cut up Italian bread and dip away. Little kids love to dip, they think its a game!
Not only do they sell Olive Oils, they sell some outrageous balsamic vinegars! I bought a red apple balsamic vinegar to have with tonights dinner. Want to impress your dinner guests? Make them a salad with a crazy olive oil or balsamic dinner purchased from The Amazing Olive. You can’t buy these products in a supermarket!
They also sell herbs, cheese boards and baskets to give a very unique gift.
I’m glad to support this business in my little seaside town :)
Place rating: 5
Port Jefferson, NY
This is a spectacular little gem on the sweetest street in Port Jefferson Village. A beautifully designed and appointed shop with a friendly welcoming management which will greet you and guide you through its vast array of incredible products. You will go back again and again. Tasting the oils and vinegars is a treat, and the owner will explain what you are tasting and recommend food pairings as well. I hated to leave! A must visit in Port Jeff, & open every day. Thanks, Ralph for an incredible addition to our village! Oh, & did I mention the bath & body products? What a treat. Go as soon as you can.
Place rating: 5
Austin, TX
The Amazing Olive is a gift and one of my favorite stores in Port Jefferson. Their flavor infused olive oils and balsamic vinegars have inspired me to try new recipes and they have revamped many of my old recipes. Additionally, the products at The Amazing Olive make great gifts! No trip to Port Jefferson is complete until you’ve visited The Amazing Olive!