Fill Yo Cup

Appears to be permanently closed all equipment and seating has been removed just bare walls remain

Cute and nice froyo place. Tart flavor is good and fruit is fresh. Owner was really nice.

eyyo, fill yo cup!
this spot is pretty good to chill with some friends or satisfy your sweet tooth… not the best, but definitely not bad. a very welcome addition to the area with some room for improvement.
the yogurt here is definitely on the sweet side, and there weren’t any tart flavors today. the graham cracker flavor was actually delicious, as were the other choices i sampled– but they were way sweet.
two toppings bars– one with fruit (small selection, but fresh, clean, etc), and the other with cookie and candy bits, nuts, etc. most of the usual suspects. caramel, fudge sauce, marshmallow fluff, etc. to top it all off too. would be nice to see more fruit options, and i miss the little cheesecake bits that nearby fro-​yo places offer (Twist, Yogurtland, etc).
the interior of Fill Yo Cup is large and spacious– plenty of flat screen TVs and an electric fireplace. one of the TVs had a ms. pac man joystick game hooked up– that was fun. love the joystick. love getting my nerd on. fun seating options and free wi-​fi make this a good spot to hang with some friends… there aren’t many places to do so in WWP.
will have to give this place another try in the summer– maybe when business volume is up, they’ll have more flavor and topping options…

Quite possibly the rudest owners, management and staff I have ever encountered. Surprising for an establishment that is always completely empty; you would think they would want to make their few customers feel welcome. The froyo and toppings left much to be desired. I will not go back.

Setting: Winter… the day after Christmas
— The business was so completely empty that I bought a mini tiramisu cake out of pity. (They now sell baked goods in addition to froyo.)
— Maybe the woman in charge was just trying to be helpful, but it seemed like she kept trying to advertise everything in her store. Unless there’s something remarkably unique about a product, there’s no reason to continuously talk. Keep it short or don’t say anything unless asked. It made me feel forced to buy something, especially since no one else was there. And it makes me hesitate to go in there again if the store is empty.
— The tiramisu was a little too much rum for me (the bottom layer), but overall decent, and not overly sweet.
— They had free sample of cookies by the counter… unfortunately they were quite possibly the worst chocolate chip cookies I’ve ever had in my life… aren’t you supposed to put out delicious things as samples to encourage customers?
— Overall, the flavor selection of the froyo seemed very holiday-​esque. Did not have any though.
— They do sell Jarets stuffed cupcakes: she orders on Tuesday and they deliver by Thursday to the store. She has a menu that you can take home and order specific ones for pick-​up.

Super-​cute fro-​yo place! it’s still a bit of a work in process, but it impressed me the moment i walked in. On the positive side, there was TONS of seating (hopefully it gets used when this place gets more publicity!) There were televisions so we could watch the Steelers game, while a lot of current music played from another screen. I could see it being a very casual and fun place to hang out when it’s full of people.
The yogurt itself could have been a bit firmer, but they had a lot of interesting and seasonal flavors. Some were a bit too strong in sweetness, which overpowered some flavor, (salted caramel pretzel was REALLY salty, quite odd for fro-​yo!) I ended up getting both pumpkin & espresso flavors (the pumpkin had delicious pie-​like spices in it, and the bitterness from the coffee yogurt balanced out the sugary-​ness. It makes me hope for peppermint and gingerbread flavors come winter!
The toppings bar was on an island, so people could walk around rather than line up to get their favorite topping, and had tons of options! Something I’d never seen in another yogurt place was the option to make your creation in a cone rather than a cup (i’m surpised this hadn’t been done sooner!) and they’d weigh it afterwards. There was also an option to build-​your-​own smoothie if you wanted a sweet drink.
Aside from yogurt, Fill-​Yo-​Cup had a cute little pastry window in the back, which had cupcakes, pretzels, cookies, and shells (for cannolis?) available. There is coffee, cappuccinos, or espressos for those looking for a warmer pick-​me-​up. Additionally, all of the baked goods & yogurts are house-​made.
The owners were very friendly, checked with their customers’ satisfaction, and seemed very passionate and excited about their shop. I will definitely be visiting here again (and again, and again.!)

They’re a great addition to help liven the area up. Froyo — you cannot go wrong with it. Fruity Yogurt in Princeton has already set the bar for me and «Fill Yo Cup» falls short of it.
The yogurt seems watery and doesn’t hold it’s firmness well. On some spoonfuls, I felt the texture was grainy instead of being silky.
Flavor/​quality aside, what Fill Yo Cup excels in is the placement of their toppings bar. Instead of customers crowding around 1 side, they can use all 4 sides of the counter.
Décor/​environment– it seems hip. The pull-​out chairs are unique and gives the place a relaxed atmosphere.
The spacing inside is both it’s strength and its downfall. While it’s nice not to have to be within earshot of other customers, there’s also unnecessary dead space inside. Maybe adding some more high chairs/​tables could help; maybe it wasn’t crowded enough.
Overall, not a bad place. Rather than heading to Princeton and deal with the traffic, you can come here with ample parking space. Hopefully they can improve their froyo quality in the future.

Probably the biggest froyo place I’ve been to, but most of the space is unnecessary and empty. TV screen with pop music trivia was a bit annoying. Froyo was decent, more chocolate-​type flavors than fruity, and I would have liked more variety. It had a weird vibe, though. I went on a Wednesday night at 9pm and there was a good number of people, but everyone there was middle aged or older. Super weird considering this is WWP and parents don’t go out past 7:30 for the most part. Didn’t match the modern-​ish décor at all. It seemed like the owners want it to be a hip hangout spot for teenagers, but are failing miserably. Also the name… really?

Good place! The coffee frozen yogurt is excellent.

We are thrilled with this place. The flavors actually sparkle in your mouth. We tried four: peach, pistachio, blueberry, and coffee. They were all delicious, but the coffee was an extra happy surprise. The flavor was really deep and intense. This is a nice, clean place with comfortable seating. One of the toppings was wet walnuts. YUM! You will love this place. Can’t wait to return.

I am NOT a big fan of frozen yogurt. But this place has the best frozen yogurt I ever had. Friendly service. The décor is awesome.

Lots of selections and is very clean. It’s our go to place after kids’ soccer games. I am glad it’s in the neighborhood!