Supreme Pizza

Pizza is good. Really nice people. Service is fast. We like their cheese pizza because it’s got plenty of cheese without paying for extra. My daughter always gets the Greek salad. And my son a steak bomb.

We order from here every Friday night– for a while we were getting a large cheese and sharing it, but now we always get two small pizzas. We ask for it well done and that seems to avoid the soggy crust issue we sometimes ran into in the past (not the whole thing, just the middle of the large pizza was sometimes not well done enough for our taste). The small pizzas well done are perfect! Chewy crust, tangy sauce and just enough cheese. So good!
We often stop in for a buffalo chicken salad on weeknights too when we need something quick for dinner. It is spicy, be warned. The buffalo fingers are like flat chicken fingers with hot sauce on them– not thick and breaded, and not a thick sauce.
Maria and Al are very nice, shy, but once you get to know them they are very friendly!

Most restaurants have at least one good attribute. This place has ZERO. Like that one review from al said the cook is always sweating, wears no gloves when preparing food. If you ran a black light thru that place the amount of bodily fluids you would see would give a forensic scientist a heart attack. If I could find a word worse than deplorable it would describe this place

i thought this was the cleanest local pizza place i have seen recently. the thick style pizza slices they serve are better than average and their small cheese pizza is very cheesey, and not too bad better for cheese lovers, I agree more spicier sauce would improve things. I also thought steak sub was not good more like overcooked beef fragments. i will keep this on my list of places to get a good slice of cheese pizza on the way to wall mart. extra credit for cleanliness. need to spice up pizzas.

I wish that this place never changed owners because the new ones are horrible. I believe its a couple running the restaurant but not 100% sure. Pizza is really hard to mess up but dammit they go a good job at it. I think it comes in frozen and they reheat it. Everything is frozen and just doesn’t taste right. Not sure if its what they cook on or cook in but it needs to be cleaned or replaced. The guy cooking looks like hot water and a bar of soap aren’t on his daily agenda. Kinda all set with a greasy dirty mess cooking my food. His sweat sweats he perspires so much while cooking food Starting to question whether the grease on the bottom of the pizza box is from the food or the cook’s hands.

should have known better as at high noon there was 2 other people in this place, not a good sign. They had lasagna on special so I gave it a go, and should have gave it a gone. Marie Callender or even Encore is much better. Sloppy, wet and tasteless but other than that it was great.

ugh, not good at all. As a part of me and my bf effort to try all the pizza places in Quincy this one comes in dead last so far of the 10 or so we have tried.
First of all. the pizza has no taste except the grease. so instantly 1 star, but to top it off they got our order wrong and the wait was kid of on the long side for a plain cheese pizza.
I don’t even think there was sauce on this pizza.

I am sad to say that I am no longer as impressed as I use to be with Supreme Pizza. Something has changed with this place…