Mr Miceli Pizza

The staff was very nice and the place was clean. I wanted to start with a positive. We didn’t like the food the sauce had no taste. We won’t be going here again.

The pizza was very very good however the service was terrible. The cleaner, a short maybe Hispanic gentlemen started yelling at my table and calling us names because we were waiting for our friend in the bathroom to go home so he can clean up sooner than later. I will never go back to this pizzeria and I will tell everyone I know in Rockville center, and Long Island, to never go back. I do not find it necessary to call somebody waiting for their friend in the bathroom a bitch. however, he told me to tell his boss so that is why this is here.

Pretty decent… I’d eat here again!

Delicious pizza. 2 plain slices 2 pepperoni and 1 bottle of water $ 14. Plenty of tables and chairs. Assortment beverages. All the patrons seem to be regulars. No complaints.

A family member of mine had recommended Mr Miceli Pizza for their large selection of gluten free items. Having a gluten allergy makes it challenging to find delicious pizza, but I found that today at Mr Miceli! Their gluten free pizza dough is made in house and it is amazing. Tastes fresh, homemade, AND gluten free! I will definitely be returning and recommending this pizzeria!

First off The owner is a classless arrogant jerk, the place is filthy, dirty & disgusting the pizza is Horrible! Taste like cardboard i think Ellio’s pizza from the frozen food section at the supermarket is better! Lol you want a real Italian pie? Try Blue Moons coal oven pizza across the street, it’s amazing, you want a nice quick tasty slice? go up the block to Sal’s, but whatever you do steer clear of this place

This place was horrible! The owner is rude and cheap. Charged us 3.00 for a pitcher of water!!! The girls that worked there were sweet but were being «watched» by the owner. We ordered 2 pies and the price changed as we were paying. I will NEVER go back to this place again! The pizza wasn’t even good, frozen pizza tastes better! It’s sad because it’s in such a nice part of RVC and probably gets business from unknowing customers!
They need to work on their recipes, as well as their customer service!

The food was amazing and the service was impeccable. We got delivery to our hotel and it was so nice to have GF options with such convenience!!!
It really left an impression. We can’t recommend it highly enough. You can tell they care.
If you’re GF and need yummy versatile options this is your place!!!

The worst Pizza I ever had in my life. I will never eat or recommend them to a living being. There was no flavor the sauce was lite and extremely bland.

I’m honestly unsure how this place has stayed in business throughout the years. The owner and most of his employees are rude, they have this go-​eff-​yourself attitude. Delivery always has cold pizza, which is sub-​par at best. I truly wish Centre slice didn’t close in RVC, it was nice having digestible pizza while it lasted. Not to mention edible pizza. Now you’re better off going to Queens or the city for a good slice. Forced to go to Gino’s which is out of the way most of the time but it’s still reliably good compared to the lackluster Miceli excuse for pizza.
I completely forgot to mention: roaches! They have huge roaches, small ones, and they’ve probably spread to any business attached to it!

We ordered a Garlic and Basil pie for a very late night pick up.
The pie had some torn basil and a lot of garlic powder — which I guess should have been expected. Unfortunately some of the garlic powder was gritty. In addition, one of us had the misfortune of biting into a small piece of plastic. Even without the extra «topping» the pizza was below average. Let’s just say that more than half of the pie went in the trash and that I would prefer pizza from national chains over the pizza I had the displeasure of experiencing here.
Also, be aware that they either add a late night surcharge or their online menu isn’t updated. We paid around $ 23 for the pie when the menu price was $ 15. We double checked whether there was a mistake with the price, but apparently not.
If you’re craving pizza at around 3AM and there’s nowhere else that’s open, still avoid! You’re better off going to the nearby 24 hour supermarket and getting a frozen pie.

The pizza we ordered was tasty. But I wanted to make a quick shout out to the delivery guy whom took our order over the phone as well tonight. Very friendly, very efficient and very speedy service. Thank you!

I grew up in RVC and gave been eating here since I was a kid. I find the pizza ok, not great and not bad but pretty reliable. They are conveniently located across the street from the movies and the owner is friendly. I will stop in either before or after catching a movie. I did just that on Saturday. My family went to the movies and then went to miceli’s. We sat down to eat regular slices and it was all fine until my sister found a hair on her pizza. It wasn’t baked in the slice so it may have been on the paper plate itself which is exactly what the owner said. And that’s about all he said. He paused and then asked if I wanted another slice. I said no thanks being skeezed out after that. We left and he didn’t even look up to say good bye. He actually avoided making eye contact. No sorry or do you want your money back. Nice customer service. I won’t be going back.

The pizza here is amazing. Been eating here since 98. Lucas the owner is the sweetest. I love that they stay open til 4am for the clubs n bars in the area, so that they have a place to eat. I’ll most likely will eat here for the rest of my life lol. :)

Mr. Miceli’s pizza is easily the BEST in Rockville Centre. The sauce, crust, cheese, and toppings are perfect.

It was roomy here because this is Long Island and eateries here don’t try to make you sit on your neighbor’s lap. It wasn’t immaculate here by the evening, with used napkins on the floor not picked up by the sweet wait staff who all looked under 16 and maybe didn’t know that when you see too many napkins littering the floor caused by ill mannered customers, you still need to sweep the floors. Normally I would have turned and headed out. But the posters were amusing, and the pizza was sold by the slice, desirable because I only wanted to nibble on something savory before I headed to the ice cream parlor a few doors down. Mr. Miceli offers many varieties of what appears to be deep dish pizza, but round in shape and not made into squares. The toppings on these pies made them look thicker than normal slices, like flattened quiche. I opted for the plain cheese slice, since there were no signs that I saw and I couldn’t make out what the various pies were topped with and was too lazy to ask. Pizza was not my true objective; staving off a sugar rush was. I also like to judge a place on it’s regular cheese slice. The slice had a nice thin crust, with a good cheese to sauce ratio. Unfortunately, the slice was slightly more salty than I prefer. It was cheap at $ 2.50 and pretty big. I suspected my disappointment could have come from ordering the wrong type of slice. Everyone who came in after me seemed to get the thicker slices and they seemed to know what was what. Perhaps not a place I’d gravitate to but acceptable in a pinch. Perhaps I’d try a different kind of slice next time.

I had a slice of the «grandpa» pizza & It was delicious !!! The owner is such a nice guy … I’ll definitely be returning!

Mr. Miceli is one of the nicest and most accommodating restaurant owners I have ever met! My husband and I were only in the NYC area for 24 hours and were looking for lunch before boarding our plane to head out of the country. I stumbled across Mr. Miceli’s Pizza place on my «find me gluten free» app. I have a lot of food allergies including gluten and yeast. My husband and I were trying to figure out what to eat, and I made a comment that i can’t have the crust because of the yeast and Mr. Miceli said «oh no no, I do not have yeast in my crust». He then proceeded to make THE most delicious pizza (gluten free or not) that I have ever had in my life! It was SOOOO yummy and I wish he were here in Texas so i could have it more often! He also took pictures with my husband and was extremely personable.
If you have the chance to try Mr. Miceli’s Pizza, GO FOR IT! He is a nice man who makes really awesome pizzas.

Favorite RVC pizza! I used to come here for lunch in my less healthy days and yummm his pizza is always amazing. Haven’t been here in a while but would definitely recommend!

I’ve been eating here since I was a kid. Hands down, they serve some of the best pizza around. The specialty pies and slices are fantastic and filling. The cheese pies rock. Just enough sauce and cheese and spice to make you raise your fingers to your lips and kiss them! DELIZIOSO!!!
Mr. Miceli is a pizza place that also serves nice heros and Italian meals. The pizza is the best thing though! There’s parking in back and it’s easy to get to. Try it, you’ll like it!