Capri Bakery

Best bakery I’ve found in the area (and there’s quite a few bakeries around for competition.) Everything is made so fresh there and just tastes amazing. They make their own cannoli cream fresh, and fill the cannolis at the time of your order. They have great chocolate cigars, and great cakes. Their cannoli cake is to die for. It’s well worth the price. They top it with huge chocolate covered strawberries. It’s just next level in the realm of cakes. The cookies are very good too. Not a single thing I’ve tried there has been less than above average in quality and taste. This is my go to bakery in the area.

Best Ice Cream Eva! Beast after a burger and Fries from All American next door. The Ice Cream cakes are a must for any party.

The best pastries, cakes and bread by far! Our family has been going to Capri for many years. All of our birthday cakes have been made by Capri. We have tried other bakeries but never as good as Capri!

I give 5 stars for the fresh homemade cannolis. Best that I have ever had, hands down! They are made fresh when you order. I pass Capri a couple of times a week and I always stop by to buy a cannoli or two.

This place isn’t owned by the same owners, and hasn’t for a while, but the place is still a little treasure. My sister used to work here, 15 years ago… She used to bring home pastries that were always delicious. They have, the, best, canolies. Everyone says Dortoni’s is better, WRONG. Capri makes your canoli to order, which makes all the difference.
Try the pizza they hide in the case, its delicious.

Very tasty and fresh Italian pastry. The neapolitans were heavenly. It was light and creamy. A must try if you are in the area.

Great pastries and cookies which make perfect gifts for dinners, parties, and get-​togethers.

Capri has the best black and white cookies I have ever had. Definitely beats Fehn’s down the street. Very Italian bakery that knows how to make cookies to perfection.

Their cookies are very good. I am in love with jelly filled pastries and the rainbow cookies are great. Aside from the desserts their breads are great too. I usually go there on a weekend to make sandwiches for the week and buy their fresh bread. It’s crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. They really know how to make bread high quality. I also buy their pizza dough and make homemade pizzas during the week for a quick and easy meal.
The staff is nice and they just re-​did the place so I would recommend checking it out!

Needed to get a birthday cake for my girlfriend’s 30^th and a buddy said that Capri is amazing. I ordered their red velvet cake and when I got there the store smelled amazing. It’s a fat guys paradise in there. I had to get a couple cannolis while I was there and they didn’t survive the ride home.
The one problem for me is that this bakery is in Seaford and I’m in northern Queens… so I go there very infrequently :-(

Capri’s Bakery never gets tired. they have plenty of staff and always have customers. Store is never empty. They really mean business here… they have real italian cakes, pasteries, canoli’s and a locally renowned strawberry, canoli topped cassata and chocloate mouse cake. LOL

Best. The fresh pizza just made for lunch is the best deal around!

Capri is a Wantagh institution, and for a local, you might recognize this as the bakery on Merrick Road attached to the gift shop. I was always afraid to go in there because I knew I would knock something over. That door from the inside still haunts me. Too much ceramic. I just recognize it as Capri.
My family regularly gets their bread here. The rye or wheat is creamy and soft. When our extended family of 6 eats together, we easily knock off a loaf with a tub of olivio spread.
The cookies are solid and the cakes are fine as well. And when times are good, we may also get a slice or two of pizza. This is no brooklyn slice. They say it’s authentic, but what’s that mean? I guess it’s a bakery slice. It’s a large square pie that sits on the counter all day soaking up tomoto sauce and just a sprinkling of parmesan cheese. Not your traditional pizza… or maybe it is? It’s not mine, but it is good and I can bet that there’s foodies out there who have been dreaming of this long lost pizza for decades.
Compared to Rose and Joe’s’ pizza in Astoria, this is much better. It’s completely soft and delightful, it brings you back and makes you want to live forever.