Pagliacci Pizza

Great pizza. Fresh, creative ingredients. I’d order from there more often, but I can’t afford it.

Been going here for 9+ years and have aways have had amazing service and amazing pizza. They also serve so how slices now which is a nice option! :) they are open pretty late which is very nice and their seasonal options are always delicious!

Of all the pizza delivery places in Seattle, Pag is my favorite! I love the margherita pizza because it’s clean, low (er) calorie, and is sooo tasty! The crust is delicious and has salt flakes on it, the sauce is light and the melted cheese with basil leaves is perfection.
I also love the Pagliacci Salad but usually ask for dressing on the side or lite on the dressing as it can be a bit much. They always put dressing on the side when you order delivery.
I always have great service and really like that I can order online now!

Would have been so much better if: 1) I received the bread sticks I ordered and paid for, and even after the delivery driver (who was late in the first place) called me back to see if they were mine, I still didn’t receive them, and 2) I didn’t find a really long strand of reddish brown hair melted in the cheese of my pizza slices. I would give this place zero stars if I could. Clean up your act, guys. It’s disgusting.

I heard at a Moth performance about how good Pagliacci’s pizza was about two years ago. I’ve seen them around but never really made the effort to go try out a slice of their pizza. Recently, I got my chance. My friend bought an entire pizza (with sausage and vegetables). I thought it was okay. I didn’t think the thin crust was all that tasty. I went again myself to grab a slice and thought it was really greasy. I didn’t feel like their pizza really stood out of others that I’ve had. The crust and dough portion weren’t burnt and cooked just right though. I think its okay, not really that special.

This Pagliacci is more of a «take out» joint. Yes, they have tables and sell slices now. However, getting service may be a challenge during brisk take out periods.
I’ve had delivery from here many times. The pizza is always good and service sound. The pizza isn’t exactly cheap but that’s okay. They offer a regular menu and specials. I ordered a primo fig pizza this week. It was really good! The crust was cooked perfectly. It was covered with figs, basil, and prosciutto. The flavors worked really well together. The basil is fragrant when you bring the slice to your mouth. The salty prosciutto is complimentary to the sweetness of the figs.
Slices are a recent addition at this location. When I went in, they had three slices of three different varieties. Within 10 minutes, they had two more pies out.
Considering the other food options in the area, this is one of the more consistent businesses.

We decided to give the location on 145^th a second try after a mediocre previous experience. Had our pizzas delivered in a reasonable amount of time. But when we opened the box, our pizza was missing toppings on over a third of it. How can a pizza cost $ 20 but be so carelessly made? Also the crust was overt chewy. We did have a good slice at the West Seattle location however last month. Won’t be trying the 145^th location again though.

Delicious pizza right next door. What more could I ask for? And now they do by the slice!

Stopped in again on 6÷11÷15 after seeing signage that says this location also serves pizza slices. This only started about a week and a half ago per the counter person. This is a great idea to be able to sample a variety of what Pagliacci has to offer.
I brought home one pepperoni, two cheese slices, and two chicken and spicy pepper slices. It hit the spot for the kiddo and I and is especially convenient for a late dinner option. Make sure to pick up a pizza slices stamp card too!
I am appreciative of the continued consistency in all that this particular Pagliacci Pizza location does.

We order pizza from Pag at least 1 – 2 times a month. I have never been disappointed by the quality and their service is always stellar from putting in my order to delivery. Their 12^th Man pizza is a favorite at our house!

Terrific pizza — both basic plain cheese and exotic specials.
Delivery is totally reliable and quality is consistent.
Occasionally I get sticker-​shock at my bill for pizza but guess that’s the price of living in an expensive city.

Pagliacci Salad: Worst salad of any pizza place in town. For $ 8 they basically give you a head of lettuce and a tiny amount of toppings. Seriously a way too much lettuce. You will have to dirty some dishes to eat this salad since there is so much lettuce its jammed into the box to the point of not being able to eat it. This salad is Worthless! I should have saved my money! I would give it negative stars.

Omgosh they are just fabulous! They go out of the way to help you and get the best deal. Best pizza joint in town. The food is always the freshest in town and piping hot pizza’s right out of the oven. Never had a bad experience here. I am a customer for life. You guys are doing right up there. Thanks for being consistently great, it’s a rare quality in Seattle.

Nothing special. I think the pizzas are overpriced.
Like the salad and garlic flat bread as of the pizzas for that price do not think it’s worth the cost.

I ordered a Grand Salami pizza. It was over-​price for 13″ (tiny). The dough was over cook and dry, and the topping was greasy and tasted very salty. For $ 24 dollars, I expect much more than it. overall, I think the pizza is not worth for 24 dollars at all. I don’t know if i would go back there ever again,

The menu looks great for options. We got two pizzas that ended up just being ok. For $ 24 a pizza I expected quite a bit more for the money.

Their food in general, and particularly their pasta, is really good. We ate here a lot when we lived downtown. Do note, though, that their roosevelt way location (which is the one that delivers in shoreline) has a really reduced menu. I was really disappointed that they didn’t have most of my favorites. :(

My family is new to Seattle so one day,
My babies were asleep and it was pouring down rain. I was craving pizza so I did a quick google search and Pagliacci came up. I ordered their delivery special (buy one 11 inch pizza and get the second for 6.99) and the lady who took my order was very thorough. I requested that the driver call me once he got here because my children were sleeping. (Any mother knows how the doorbell can make a mama homocidal!) The delivery guy showed up earlier than expected with the pizza still piping hot. He was friendly as can be and my pizza tasted ahhhhhmazing! I am now currently waiting on my second pizza order and again, the person taking my order was thorough and friendly. He had my credit card on file so I didn’t have to dig my card out. Just such a nice, friendly experience. The people who I’ve talked to make me feel like family :)

Just moved to Seattle and wanted to try something other than mainstream pizza. This food is amazing. Had the chicken primo. Some people came over n loved it n had to order another an hour later. Definitely worth the extra couple dollars. Officially my favorite pizza spot. Also get the house dressing to sip it in.

This pizza was perfect.
My grandmother fell quite ill and fast… I didn’t eat the whole day while visiting her. My saint of a boyfriend said he would pick up a pizza and bring it to me.
AND HOW. The pizza with the goat cheese and veggies was amazing. It was hot and the toppings were fresh. The other pizza with meat and veggies was great too.
The next morning, we had a slice of the veggie pizza with the fried egg. Delicious!