Shelter Island Craft Brewery

Shelter Island, United States

4.3

Closed now

16 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 631-749-5977
Website:
www.shelterislandcraftbrewery.com
Address:
55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
2.3 miGreenport
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes

Today

Today 11:00 am – 8:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Shelter Island) 6:28 AM Friday, June 27, 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 8:00 pm
Tuesday –
Wednesday 11:00 am – 8:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 8:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 8:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 8:00 pm
Sunday 11:00 am – 8:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Shelter Island Craft Brewery is now OPEN! We are a local craft brewery utilizing Shelter Island ingredients in every type of beer we produce!

Vicinity

Near this location:
1
ft
Maria’s Kitchen
55 N Ferry Rd
20
ft
Black Cat Books
54 N Ferry Rd
170
ft
Bella Vita Pizza
53 N Ferry Rd
370
ft
Table of Content General Store
59 Ferry Rd
520
ft
The Islander
63 N Ferry Rd
650
ft
Marcello Masonry Inc
67 N Ferry Rd

16 reviews of Shelter Island Craft Brewery

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Manhattan, NY
I had the opportunity to visit Shelter Island Craft Brewery and I almost didn’t leave… They had some AMAZING tasting beers and James Hull, and his daughter were great hosts. I was able to sample all the beers and would recommend Montezuma Milk Stout, and their French Kiss!
Can’t wait to go back!
Place rating: 4
Levittown, NY
If you are on Shelter Island a must place to stop. Good selection of beers and good food. Get the pretzel. Best thing on the menu. Pork sliders good too! Reasonable prices and nice atmosphere.
Place rating: 4
Farmingdale, NY
Great beers. The Castagna was my favorite, but also enjoyed the Nude Beach and Forbidden Fruit. Small Indoor seating area but picnic benches outside. Overall a nice experience!
Place rating: 5
Stony Brook, NY
This place is great. Decent prices, great food. Beer felt pretty light but I enjoyed it. Would recommend the nude beach. Most of the ingredients were locally grown. Personally felt that some of the beers could have more of a bitter bite but most of my group enjoyed the beer. Would recommend!
Place rating: 1
Deer Park, NY
Not the greatest brewery. Big fan of the rest of the ones on Long Island. Don’t get me wrong this was clean but… The beers were not the greatest. Bought a groupon. 4 tasting and a growler. Walked in, saw pitchers of foam. The kegs were not working properly. Almost pure foam. The daughter of the owner looked preoccupied or not into her job. Took her about 5 min to interact with us. Only about 10 people total inside. All the other breweries I have been to, customers got to choose the beers. Apparently, she chooses the beers for us. The owner looked overwhelmed. Not interactive. I did not even bother to get the free growler.
Place rating: 1
Deer Park, NY
I was not impressed with the beer at all. 2 of them tasted like you were drinking soap, 1 was way too sweet and 1 was way too hoppy. The brewery itself seemed nice but small, and the draft system looked like it was a homemade kit they bought of the Internet. The beers poured warm and foamy. Both the owner and the daughter were disengaged from the customers, they seemed preoccupied and that having customers were an inconvenience to them. I have no desire to ever go back.
Place rating: 5
Huntington, NY
Love this place. Discovered it by accident while on Shelter Island. Spoke to the owner who gave us the/​his very interesting history. Charming, original. GREAT music playlist that the owner told us he created himself. Excellent beer and food. Bought glasses, growlers and a hat, we loved it so much.
Place rating: 5
Lindenhurst, NY
They’re brewing up something good in Shelter Island… see what i did there? LOL All puns aside, this place is a welcomed addition to the area and they are cranking out some serious brews. It’s a great spot to enjoy some suds especially in their outdoor seating area. They have some bites to eat as well, of which i highly recommend the pretzel and the bacon brittle… yes you read that right.
If you are nearby or just passing through you should stop by and have a beer, it’s worth it!
Place rating: 5
LEONARDO, NJ
Great Beer & Snacks n in Sleepy Shelter Island… a must to stop in for a pint/​tasting!
Place rating: 5
Setauket- East Setauket, NY
We heard this brewery was new so we decided to give it a shot instead of our usual greenport run. We were pleasantly surprised! Not only was the atmosphere really nice but the beer tastes just as good! Outdoor sitting and indoor seating. I was surprised they didn’t have a tasting option but I’m sure they’ll be adding that option shortly.
Place rating: 4
Fort Greene, NY
Beer speaks for itself — which is a relief because the servers wouldn’t.
Lots of unfiltered ales that have flavorful fruit additives (e.g., plums and grapefruit). Group favorite was the Nude Beach.
Place rating: 5
Trumansburg, NY
Excellent beer! I recommend the Twin Forks Harvest Ale and the Nude Beach… they are just starting out show them some love and stop for a beer! I will be back for more!
Place rating: 5
Bradenton, FL
No review because they weren’t open. Looks pretty good from the outside though. if we are ever back on SHelter Island we will return to sample the craft beer.
Place rating: 5
Greenfield, MA
A welcome addition to the island! Great small batches of beer. They brew half barrel kettles so get here early or they will be sold out!
They also have snacks for all dietary needs including gluten free and vegan though not labeled as such.
Come sit outside on their picnic tables on a beautiful day and enjoy your brew! The IPA is 6.5% ABV and is dark but very tasty.
Place rating: 5
Winston-Salem, NC
Awesome atmosphere, great staff and most importantly — great brew. Must see stop on the island.
Place rating: 5
Floral Park, NY
Awesome little place. My girlfriend and I were biking around Shelter Island and stumbled along this little haven. Walking inside I found a great find. The brewery has several different brews, all good. Also, according to the gentleman who served us, all the ingredients are from the local area. Definitely will come back here next time I am around Shelter Island.