Joe’s & Vinny’s Pizzeria

It is challenging to find a good pizza shop or restaurant in the smaller towns of central NY but at Joe’s & Vinny’s I always get a great piece of pizza here! The Buffalo Chicken Wing pizza — Delish! Also, get the fresh filled when you order Cannoli — Yum!

We recently started eating dinner here. The dining room is in the back. There is a parking lot in the back of the building and you can walk right into the restaurant from back there and seat yourself in the dining room. Be careful outside … The parking lot needs repair. I think it’s a village-​owned lot and not the restaurant’s responsibility.
The dining room itself leaves a lot to be desired. Several booths wrap around the walls of the room. In the middle of the room you will find some tables with folding metal chairs.
So why do we go there about once a week for dinner? The food. It is very good and you get large portions. I have ordered the Chicken Parmesan dinner frequently. It is delicious and there is enough to take home for another meal. It is served with a side salad and bread. The salad is better than most side salads you get out. Plenty of cheese and vegetables.
I have also recently tried their cold subs. The mixed meat and the chicken tender subs are both really good. Fresh bread, plenty of meat and cheese (for my taste).
When I order take out, I generally get their Chicken Tender Salad. I order the large portion. Again, it’s very good because of the things they put on it. Plenty of chicken, cubes of cheese, tomato, cucumber, onion, etc. It comes with Italian bread.
The staff out front taking to-​go orders on the phone and giving you your order when you pick it up is your typical teenage staff. They provide adequate service but aren’t overly friendly. The waitresses back in the dining room are very good. They check on you frequently, are very friendly and provide a pleasant experience.

I would come back here. This isn’t too far from my grandparent in law’s house so we stopped here for lunch. It was around my 2 year old’s nap time so he was a little crazy, but we did not get any grief whatsoever from the waitress; she even brought his food out first.
Three of us got calzones and my mother in law got a salad. While I’ve had better calzones, my father in law raved about his and said it was better than the ones he gets in New York City. I think the fact that I got green peppers in mine made it a bit watery. Still, it didn’t stop me from eating it and taking the rest home.
The pizza by the slice was very good; I’d go back for that alone.

Good food. Great wings. No Sunday hours which sucks for football season. Also prices are way to high. Customer service is lacking to say the least.

Joe & Vinny’s has always been a reliable source for decent pizza in Sidney. It’s relatively inexpensive, tastes great, and isn’t overly greasy. They make a solid cheese pizza, and have good non-​traditional ones like chicken wing pizza.
I’m not a huge fan of their wings (I prefer a thicker sauce that sticks to the chicken wings, and they don’t seem to make the wings spicy enough for my liking) but have always been happy with their pizza, garlic knots, and calzones/​stromboli.

Came over 4^th of July weekend. Walked in and hotter than heck, no AC. its a typical pizzeria joint with counter service and soda pop up front with two dilapidated laminate booths to sit in. There’s a main dining room out back that looks like the worst cafeteria I ever ate in… uncomfortable laminate booths crammed in on top of each other… No AC back here either. The pizza slices on display looked dried out like it had been sitting there for hours… we lasted a total of 10 minutes. Sat down ordered drinks… and watched the sweat roll down our face… looked at each other and said what the hell are we doing here? Got up and went to Roma’s…I recommend you do the same.