Yogurtini Self Serve

Smithtown, United States

4.2

Open now

14 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 631-656-5955
Website:
www.yogurtini.com
Address:
44 E Main St, Smithtown, NY, 11787
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
0.3 miSmithtown
2.5 miSt. James
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Parking
Street
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free

Today

Today 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Open now
Local time (Smithtown) 10:55 PM Friday, May 30, 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 11:00 pm
Sunday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm

Description

Specialties

We serve 16 kinds of Frozen Yogurt every day with 65 kinds of toppings including fresh fruit, nuts, grains and candies.

History

Established in 2012.

Created by Tempe, AZ natives and sisters, Natasha Nelson and Chelsey Nelson, Yogurtini Self Serve Frozen Yogurt offers up to 16 rotating healthy and fat-​free frozen yogurt flavors and over 65 toppings. Yogurtini only serves real yogurt that contains live and active cultures approved by the National Yogurt Association. The popularity of Yogurtini and the brand has been recognized by customers and the press in its native Arizona, where readers recently voted Yogurtini as «Favorite Place to Chill» in 944 Magazine and «Best Sweet Spot» in College Affair Magazine.

Yogurtini keeps in touch with its customers through its social networking programs on Facebook, Twitter or our Blog. YHI, Inc is the franchise development company for Yogurtini. Learn more about franchising at website franchise link. Yogurtini offers frozen yogurt franchise area development agreements. Additional Yogurtini franchises are under construction and development across the USA!

Meet the Business Owner

Ellen B.

Business Owner

Coming Soon — Please check back!

Related places

You might also consider:
1
mi
Carvel
Vetrns Memrl Hwy
1.2
mi
Ralph’s Famous Italian Ices
316 Maple Ave
1.3
mi
Friendly’s
220 Mount Pleasant Road
1.4
mi
Dunkin Donuts Baskin Robbins
559 Smithtown Byp
2
mi
Carvel Ice Cream
680 Middle Country Rd
2.4
mi
Bobby’s Cheese N’ Freeze
601 Veterans Hwy

Vicinity

Browse nearby places:
10
ft
The UPS Store
34 E Main St
20
ft
Costello’s Ace Hardware Store
52 E Main St
20
ft
GND Marketing
34 E Main St Ste 190
20
ft
Lock and Tech USA
34 E Main St
20
ft
Main Street Meats
36 E Main St
40
ft
Bodyworx Tanning
24 E Main St

14 reviews of Yogurtini Self Serve

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Patchogue, NY
The frozen yogurt here is delicious! They have a variety of flavors. They also have sugar free vanilla which can be topped with something healthy like nuts and berries. They have a lot of other fm great toppings, too. It is priced by weight, but if you give them your phone number they text you discounts all of the time like $ 5 fill up your cup, etc.
Place rating: 4
St. James, NY
Love this place! The yogurt and toppings stations are always very clean and presentable. Yogurtini often has great rewards through their rewards system and on Groupon. The last time I was there, they were doing a «fill your cup for $ 5» promotion… naturally I took «full» advantage (see what I did there? Please don’t hate me.).
Yogurtini is much better than the Red Mango that used to be in the next shopping center over. Since it’s one of the few fro-​yo places in Smithtown, I hope it’s here to stay!
Place rating: 5
Smithtown, NY
Finally a review for a day I actually went into Yogurtini, remembered to check in, and remembered to take a picture.
This was the ultimate experience for these reasons…
1.) $ 5 fill your cup
2.) I felt deserving of froyo after a 8 mile run
3.) NSA Vanilla (80 cal), and it tastes
4.) I was the only customer bc of my weird timing
5.) toppings were fresh and plentiful
6.) DID I MENTION $ 5 FILL YOUR CUP
Yogurtini has amazing coupon opportunities, awesome flavor selection (I’m super healthy and go for tart or NSA vanilla almost always), and endless toppings!
If you’re as much a health fiend as myself, you’ll love the assortment of fruit, ground flax, several nut varieties, granola, yogurt chips, as well as the honey and cinnamon.
Nothing beats Yogurtini, just another rave review!
Place rating: 4
Kings Park, NY
Now that Red Mango around the corner has closed, I’ve been on a hunt for my new favorite frozen yogurt place. Well thank you Yogurtini, you’re it! Clean, awesome selection of flavors and toppings, nice area to sit and enjoy your fro-​yo, and friendly staff who greeted me upon entering and as I exited. I had crème brûlée and cake batter flavors tonight. Both were so good! Didn’t taste like chemicals or artificial. And I loved the cannoli shells as a toppings choice. I had one in my cup and it was delicious! I’ll definitely be coming back and doing so quite often!
Place rating: 4
New York, NY
For my 2nd froyo experience, I’ve got to say this spot is good. The flavors/​toppings choices are endless, the staff are friendly, and with a group-​on, pricing was just perfect for a large cup.
If it wasn’t so far out from me I would become a regular.
Place rating: 1
Islip, NY
Woman Owner behind the counter has a real problem putting a smile on her face and being warm and welcome to customers. Yogurt has no flavor, hard to even tell what flavor it is if you dont read the sign of what it is. Super over priced compared to most placed
Place rating: 2
New York, NY
DO NOT go here on a Friday night. Every single 7 – 10 year old in Smithtown go there and their parents let them run wild. The workers have no control and as a result are snippy and disingenuous. The serving stations are a mess and all the kids have their hands in their mouth and then on the serving utensils.
Place rating: 5
Long Island, NY
I still love you Yogurtini. Service is always with a smile. Place is always clean. I always get the sea salt caramel pretzel with heath bar crunchies.
It’s an addiction. Come here for your froyo fix.
Place rating: 5
Syracuse, NY
I’m in love with the coconut macaroon fro-​yo!!! The chocolate caramel flavor is also very delicious!
They also have strawberry boba berries as a topping– a very rare find in the fro-​yo world. They are like heaven when paired with anything chocolate.
It seems like there’s a new fro-​yo place opening up every few minutes, in every town, within a 2 mile radius of each other. Sometimes it’s hard to tell the difference between them all. But don’t be mistaken… because Yogurtini is by far THE BEST fro-​yo place I’ve ever been to!!!
Place rating: 5
Centereach, NY
The owner & employees are always cheerful and welcoming. I feel like my business is appreciated and not to mention the yogurt is delicious. The place is clean, bright and beautiful. I am frequently in Smithtown (visiting Liberty Tattoo Company, and seeing plays) and I have made extra trips just to visit Yogurtini!
Place rating: 5
Northport, NY
Finally got out to Yogurtini I really enjoyed it
There are 16 flavored to pick from so there is something for everybody. The girl working there offered us samples while we were checking out the flavors which made it easy to get something you like. I had the coconut macaroon, it was delish! and it wasnt too sweet or artificial tasting at all. There are tons of toppings to pick from too. It’s self serve so you can get exactly what & how much you want. The prices are very reasonable. I wish I lived closer, I want more!!!
Place rating: 5
Smithtown, NY
This place is awesome. The yogurt selection is always awesome and they definitely have the best add ins. They are super clean inside and the staff is super friendly. The prices are perfect for froyo (just watch how much you fill those cups!) the atmosphere really adds to the experience there as well.
This is the by far the best frozen yogurt place in smithtown. It seriously puts red mango to shame.
They have an awesome easy rewards program that doesn’t spam your email and it just sends you updates to your phone every now and again.
I would recommend this place to anyone who likes frozen yogurt. Hands down awesome.
Place rating: 5
Parkland, FL
Our new fro-​yo go-​to in Smithtown. Delicious unique flavors and fresh, amazing, huge assortment of toppings. Owner is on-​site and the young girls who work behind the counters are so friendly. The place is also spotless clean.
My favorite is the sea salt caramel pretzel flavor and I topped it with dark chocolate chips and wet walnuts which was AMAZING! My only hope is that it’s really low fat and low cal. Note that the «small» cup is gigantic so if you’re counting calories, make sure to not fill that cup up!
Place rating: 5
Smithtown, NY
Went here yesterday with a friend & it was so good brought the family back last night too! It’s very clean & the fro yo tasted great! The owner is very nice & she pays extra close attention to people with nut allergies. The peanut butter is always separate from the rest & they will take toppings from the back to make sure there is no cross contamination, as long as you ask. I felt very confident eating here that I would be totally safe. Can’t wait to go back!