We love rustic mountain! Best pizza in town! Love there sauce! My dad is very picky he however loves it! Can’t go wrong with the cheese bread sticks! Love them as well, check out there pizza cards to get a free one now and then. Good ice cream to top off the deal. Fast service, convenient parking and nice staff!
Karen D.
Place rating: 1 Clinton, IA
TERRIBLE. I would not recommend this place to anyone. Not only is the food very bland… But the staff is incredibly rude. I had ordered a steak and cheese pizza, they had delivered a steak and cheese sandwich. When I called them to inform them of the mistake, they said it was my fault that I was not clear what I wanted, but if I made up the price difference, they would run me the pizza. I said to her that I specifically ordered a pizza and she told me no that’s not what I said. Became very argumentative with me on the phone so I hung up. I would definitely not recommend this trashy place.
Taimur M.
Place rating: 5 Mott Haven, Bronx, NY
I ordered this on my stopover in Donegal, PA. I live near NYC, and I have frequented Artichoke Pizza, DiFarra’s, etc, and I must say this is some of the best Pizza I have every had. I can’t understand why, it must be the farm fresh ingredients, because it is in the middle of farmland. The tomato sauce was sweet, the vegetables were fresh, and the bread and cheese tasty. A hidden gem in the Allegheny Mountains.
Mike D.
Place rating: 3 Washington, DC
Ordered a meatball and chicken parm sub to our condo at 7springs. The content of the subs(meatballs and chicken parm) were pretty good; however, the sub roll they use is overly sweet tasting and off putting. I took the middle out and put it on some bread and it was tasty. Haven’t tried their pizza.
Chad G.
Place rating: 4 Aspinwall, PA
Excellent pizza! They deliver to hidden valley which is s huge plus. Price is great and I really enjoyed their white pizza.
C F.
Place rating: 5 Downtown, Pittsburgh, PA
Great pizza that delivers to Hidden Valley. The people that work there are friendly. I love the Bacon Ranch pizza. Homemade ice cream sandwiches are great. It’s cash only so drive down the road to the gas station to use their ATM to get cash. I wouldn’t recommend eating at the restaurant but rather getting delivery or taking out.
Arny T.
Place rating: 1 Fayetteville, NC
The exterior is not the nicest(older and mismatched tables and chairs plus HEAPS of children’s toys strewn about), but I generally don’t let looks put me off of a place. Watched one staff member come out and smoke among the tables(ok if you’re a smoker I guess, but I found it very unappealing). Ordered a Stromboli and took it to go. I dipped that thing in the sauce provided, and I could barely choke it down. That marinara sauce was outright sugary! I mean, it almost could have passed for maple syrup. I let someone else try it who also thought the sweetness was really unpleasant in a tomato sauce. I offered a third person a sample who declined after seeing the two of us wince and scowl upon taste test. I finished the rest of the Stromboli dry. The bread component was pretty good, but the rest was just okay. Definitely not a great way to spend $ 8.
Nunya B.
Place rating: 4 Somerset, PA
The pizza here is among the best I have ever had. Prices are reasonable — staff is very friendly and the food beats ANY chain place by FAR! In fact — locally — this IS the best place for pizza!
Sarah C.
Place rating: 5 Oak Park, IL
Super great pizza! Interesting sauce. Wish we had it back home near Chicago! Fast delivery too!
David R.
Place rating: 4 Potomac, MD
Rustic Mountain Pizza is in a small, unobtrusive building on Glades Pike that’s easy to miss. But when you stop(and you should!) you’ll find that inside it’s like the outside – very simple – but you also see that they have one huge, very modern pizza oven, and they serve quite a variety of pizza and subs and grilled foods. The best choice, though, is the house specialty – the pizza. You’ll like it! Further good news is that they deliver, so if you’re at Hidden Valley they are just down the street. A phone call and you have your pizza! Recommended.