Penn Station East Coast Subs

This place has probably the best sandwich I’ve ever had. I’ve had 3 different sandwiches and they have all been fantastic. The club is my favourite. Subway, Jersey Mikes, Jimmy Johns have got nothing on this place.

Penn Station East Coast Subs is my new hoagie addiction!
The hoagies here are very satisfying. It seems like anything you order here you can not go wrong with. So far I ordered the Italian and the club. I got them both toasted and man o man they were delicious. The cheese just mixes with the meat and other fixings to make a quality meal.
The ordering here is somewhat odd but it is set up so that you get your chips and drinks last.
The people working here are very friendly and will happily answer any questions you may have about your meal.
Overall it’s a great meal for a quick lunch or dinner.

We have been to this shop twice now around lunchtime during the week. There have been quite a few people there both times, but we still were able to order and find seats easily. The set up is basically like a Schlotzsky’s (Sp?) in that they make hot sandwiches. The menu offers a few unique sandwiches, and with that higher prices. Both times I have gotten a club sandwich which were good both times. You can get chips or fries with your meal, but there are not combos that I saw. Wait, I do believe that the sandwich of the week can be purchased in a combo, but any other sandwich you have to add on to your meal… which raises the price. When we were there the first time we signed up for their email club and afterward I received a Buy One Get One deal. Sweet! But we still ended up paying almost $ 19 when we went back: one sandwiches (the second was free), two fries, two drinks, one cookie. Yikes!
The restaurant itself is nice and clean, the employees are very friendly and accommodating, and the food is good. I say they are accommodating because the first time we were there the gal taking our order specifically asked if I wanted my club sandwich cold. YES! The second time we went I spaced on specifying COLD and it came out hot and toasted. I never send food back but I just am not a fan of hot turkey sandwiches (first world problems, I know) and for the amount we paid for that sandwich… So the kid graciously remade my sandwich, which I really appreciated. My fault but it was great of them to remake my sandwich without giving me a hard time.
Will we go back? I don’t know. Those prices…

Sorry, penn station. Average food, at best. Ridiculous small meat portions. Missing ingredients on 3 of 5 sandwiches. Staff was nice and accommodating with their errors. Kids sausage sandwich had .75 ounces of sausage (yes, I have a scale because I’m a calorie counting nerd). An 8 inch Philly cheesesteak had 2.8 ounces beef, but should have 6 – 7 ounces. This is very competitive area. I hope they prosper, but without improvements I don’t think they’ll last too long.

It’s been a few years since I had a penn station sub. I was thrilled to learn there was a location near great wolf lodge. All 4 subs we ordered were perfect. If you haven’t tried them yet, give them a chance it’s a great sub sandwich.

Went there for lunch recommended by my coworker. It was alright. Had there Philly cheese steak. It was ok. The guy brought me the wrong order. I ordered no mustard or mayonnaise, but they gave me my coworkers order. Mustard and mayonnaise foes not belong on a cheese steak. The bread is good.

The sandwich was really good! 6″ Philly was more like an 8″ and stuffed with cheese, meat & onions.
Employees weren’t the brightest, but the Manager was very welcoming, kind and concerned that we liked our food.
Much better than Subway or Jersey Mike’s. This place would be my first choice when going for a sub.

Great fries! Good cheesesteak. Really good chocolate chip cookies! I hear the chicken parmesan sandwich is great. Biggest problem is they are slow as molasses regardless of what time of day or how many customers are there. I know that it takes a whole to cook but I’m talking 20 minutes to make 2 sandwiches when there are 2 customers in the store. I not for the extreme wait this would be 4.5 stars.