Sunset Pizzeria

This pizzeria is great! I order from here all the time usually take or or delivery. I definitely recommend the penne vodka, it’s delicious. The buffalo chicken pie is really good and their grandma pie with vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella is delicious. They also have a grilled chicken panini with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers on a garlic knot kind of roll. There’s something for everyone here. You can also order online thru their website.

Excellent! Grandma pizza is perfection! Thin crust, fresh mozzarella, just enough sauce and spices…, just like grandma made!

Owner is such a nice man, appreciates your business and makes delicious pizza. When Sandy struck he made his dough by hand and made sure every customer was able to get pizza no matter how busy he was because few restaurants were open and most people had no power.

Ok. So good fellas was in this plaza. And we would always get their chicken franchisee and margarita and plain pies from there. We called them one day to pick up a chicken franchise and they told us that they had bought goodfellas. We asked them if they had that type of pie and they said of course we have all the cooks from there to our shop. That was BS. The pie was the most disgusting thing I had. It was cut up grilled chicken on some thick bread and thick cheese that kept hardening while we ate it. That was hard to eat. It was absolutely not a chicken franchise pie. Before we asked if thy can do it. Maybe they could say that they couldn’t have done it. Don’t say u can do something when u can’t!!! And we ended up paying the «specialty» pie price An was ripped off. We threw half the pie out. We were starving. We called them to tell them our bad experience. And they said «ok» they def. lost many customers. Hope they go outta business!!! They suck! It was pretty much cheese bread with fake chicken. Lets just keep it at that! Wow! Don’t even go to try them out!!! For ur own good. Unless u wanna be sick all night !

Best pizza at a great price!

My family and I have been going to this pizzeria for over ten years. Their pizza is fantastic; always fresh and delicious! We love their pasta vodka pie, buffalo chicken pie, & their new BBQ Chicken pie! Also, they have recently renovated and the pizzeria looks beautiful! Plus, the service here is the best! The staff is always friendly and their deliveries are always quick! I highly recommend giving this pizzeria a try!

One of the very best pizzarias on Staten Island! Great riceballs and a good selection of pastas, pizzas, heroes and more!

Pizza’s ok. They’re Italians dishes are pretty good. My fav has to be the rice ball parmesean. It’s definitely a goto in my book!