Pizza, stromboli and subs are all excellent. Stromboli is especially good with the spicy sauce(not overly spicy but slightly different than the regular sauce). They also have boneless wings. My favorite is the the garlic parmigian sauce with them. Servings are plentiful and the prices are good. Wonderful owners and staff. Never hesitate to eat here when I’m in town.
Glenn W.
Place rating: 4 Sunbury, OH
Been in Sunbury now for three years and finally got around to trying Long Branch pizza. Ordered three pizzas and one Stromboli. The online menu leaves something to be desired. For example the Stromboli isn’t on the menu. 2 cheese pizzas and one supreme. Pizzas were delicious but the crust is a little thin for my taste. The crust ended up being a little soggy due to the generous toppings. The Stromboli was DELICIOUS. Perfectly cooked and tasty. All in all, we will definitely be back.
Mike M.
Place rating: 4 Columbus, OH
Wow… stromboli is great. Loved the cheese pizza as well. Heard great things about them. Rarely does a pizza place live up to the hype. Everyone thinks their local pizza shop is the best. I live on the east side of Columbus and traveled 30 mins to try. It most diffently lived up to to the hype. My only beef was they didn’t have any boneless wings.
Brian D.
Place rating: 4 New Albany, OH
The sauce, the sauce, the sauce…it’s all about the sauce. Longbranch’s sauce has an absolutely aching back, because it really caries the rest of this pizza. The dough is very dense and chewy. Not bad, but not great. It’s thicker than most Ohio pizzas, but still square cut. Toppings do not go edge to edge, which I prefer. As to the toppings, the peps were nice. .. the shrooms were not fresh. The sauce then rode in on a white horse, picked up the blanched shrooms and carried it all to a glorious end. Seriously, this sauce is a perfect blend of sweet, herby, tomatoey(yeah, I’m making up words now) and savory. Over all, this pizza is much better than most places around. I’d go high 3 to low 4 on the stars.
John S.
Place rating: 5 Sunbury, OH
The Stromboli is fantastic here. If you get pizza ask for the spicy sauce. Very friendly locally owned business.
Kimberly S.
Place rating: 5 Marengo, OH
We just moved to the area & I’ve been craving pizza like crazy. But not«chain pizza» ya know? So I called this place, the owner(Josh) was super nice & says they can accommodate dine in. It’s late(ish) on a Sunday,(2000) & we have a fussy 18 month old. So it was a crap shoot either way. But this place was great! Cute seating area with some big TV’s, the kitchen is in the back. We ordered potato skins, hot wings & the Old World pizza. Potato skins came out first & they were great(they were very generous with the cheese & bacon). The wings were good & hot, we got a baker’s dozen. They were crispy, but not fried, which is awesome. The pizza however was the star of the show. It hit the spot perfectly! It was smoky, sweet & spicy at the same time. It was loaded with different cheeses & some special pepperoni. The crust was perfect. Crispy & right between normal/thin. We left pretty much as they were closing(2100) & the owner insisted the mess the baby left was OK, which helped me feel better about leaving said mess behind. Bottom line, BESTPIZZA I’VEHADSINCEMOVINGTOCOLUMBUS. You’re missing out if you’ve not had it. I’m happy to have found a local pizza joint with a mom & pop feel. We’ll be returning.
Dl C.
Place rating: 4 Westerville, OH
Ran into this little pizza shop. The owners are fantastic in their customer service. We decide to eat in. We had a Pep, Mushroom, and Bacon pizza. The crust was great, the toppings were a lot. It tasted great. We will be back for more and would recommend this place to others. They also deliver in a 10 mile radio us of the store.