Cooley’s Pizza

Have ordered from here so many times. Even before they moved. Today I ordered for delivery at 611. Order didn’t come until 740. This only happened after my husband called to check on the order. When it finally arrived our order was not complete. When I called to speak to the manager, he was busy. I complained to whom ever answered the phone and he said he could comp us the salad. Which we still don’t have. Won’t be back.

I love Cooleys! My job is in the same plaza so I get it quite often. Their pizza is the bomb, I could literally eat it every day. The garlic balls, are to die for. The small calzones are a great size! The owner is very nice and the facility is clean and welcoming!

This is our go-​to place for pizza delivery. We love their wings, and the delivery folks are always really nice. The food comes hot. What’s not to love?

Great Delivery Service. The people have always been friendly as well. Personally, I’m not fond of very spicy meats or sauces but they have a great blend of flavor and the ingredients seem to be fresh.

Was hoping to find a new pizza delivery place. Greek Salad dressing is amazing! However the pizza was subpar. Bummer

I LOVE this pizza. We stop in about once a week and get one. The taste is great! The place is nice, clean, nothing fancy. The owner is a nice guy too. I love supporting small local businesses. :)

I was a little skeptical ordering pizza from a place that sells chicken wings that are baked not fried. Pizza tasted similar to a chain pizzeria. Very thin and light crust.

Where to start with this. We’ve recently moved to the area and was looking for «our» new pizza spot as we generally steer clear from the mass chains like Dominos, Pizza hut etc.
Found Cooley’s Pizza online with an abundance of great reviews. How or why they have gotten these 4* & 5* reviews is beyond me.
We ordered an XL Greek Pizza for delivery and it was, for lack of a better word, terrible. The pizza was undercooked, greasy (hard to get thin crust greasy), lukewarm and completely bland. They use a pre-​made crust ala CiCis (the one with the small holes at the bottom of the crust) and the toppings didn’t even adhere to the crust. The «dipping sauce» they added to the pizza tasted… odd.
Not even worth calling and complaining as they would surely just offer you a free pizza which we want no part of.
If you enjoy your pizza greasy, cold and tasteless then this is your place. If not, steer clear!

Great pizza, great prices and great location! Called in our order and received great service and was provided was told about the deals which led is to go all out and get a second lol
We will definitely have Cooley’s again!

Visited Cooley’s Pizza to pick up dinner for the family last night. Greeted at front by the owner, Andy (super nice guy) and asked for recommendations. Based on his suggestion I ordered the Hoyt’s Firebird for myself and a cheese for the kids. The pizza was prepared quickly and I was on my way. The food was awesome! Once my kids devoured their pizza they helped me finish off mine. The Firebird was unique and one of the best pizzas I have every had. I look forward to going back and trying some of their other specialty pizzas.

Several years ago, we Took advantage of a coupon offer try out Cooley’s pizza. Since then we have never ordered pizza from anyone else! The pizza is always out of this world, the wings are fantastic, and the service is spectacular!