Our order(one pizza) took about 45 minutes to be served to us. It’s also a little pricey for a pizza. After we paid, our waiter came outside and forced us to pay an extra $ 20 because we didn’t give her the right change. Very disappointed by the waiters, but the food was great.
Bryce G.
Place rating: 1 Frederick, OK
After paying the waitress for our meal and going outside she came out and told us we are twenty short. We gave her the right amount but it got lost somewhere from the table to the front apparently… So we had to pay an extra twenty for nothing. Because the money was lost somewhere on the way to the cash register.
Kate S.
Place rating: 5 Broken Arrow, OK
Wow… good food, good prices and good service. The triple crown of small town eateries. I ordered the arti toast for an appetizer and meatball and artichoke sub for lunch and it was amazing. The staff, while colorful, with their orange and pink hair, were very respectful and attentive. Right smack in downtown Tahlequah, it has homey charm. They are open Sundays, while most of downtown is closed. Go visit, you won’t be disappointed.
Beto G.
Place rating: 5 Stillwater, OK
Quit telling everyone about this hidden gem. Tried the Arti Pie and it is my new favorite. Never disappointed
Ed H.
Place rating: 5 Rogers, AR
This place is great. The mushroom caps are a must, and the chicken BBQ pizza was fantastic. Good service and the chicken theme is hilarious.
Eric J.
Place rating: 5 Tahlequah, OK
Delicious pizzas and meatball subs. That is all I have had, but it is very good.
Eric L.
Place rating: 5 Oklahoma City, OK
A gem of a pizza place. Get the side salad, some caps and a pie. Alisa was a delight to have as a server. She was very attentive and friendly. What a fantastic place to have, in NE Oklahoma. It’s worth the drive, even if it’s a bit out of your way.
Bill J.
Place rating: 5 Roswell, NM
Amazing. Ate there on Sunday and just finished the left overs for lunch today. I owned a pizza place and hands down what we made in the fast food side does not even compare to this pizza. Lots of cheese and the toppings were amazing. Thick pieces of ham and veggies. We ordered two of the supreme and one all meat pizza. I would recommend both of them. We live in Tulsa but I would make a day trip out of this place anytime. Great pizza great atmosphere. I can’t wait to go back.
Alexander G.
Place rating: 4 Claremore, OK
Today was a fast lunch day, and the first choice Sam & Ella’s. The Chicken BBQ is terrific.
Ashley O.
Place rating: 5 Tahlequah, OK
I’ve only been here a couple of times but I love it! Right across from the park so it’s nice to sit outside and enjoy your meal. The ArtiToast is absolutely DELICIOUS! I had no idea I even liked artichokes– apparently I love them! The sandwiches are good and the pizzas are tasty. The service was good and friendly, we were still checked on often even when we sat outside. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in the area!
Blake M.
Place rating: 5 Hayesville, NC
I had heard that this was the place to eat. Let me give you my run down. Cheap prices, great food, amazing and large portion sizes, friendly employees and clean. If you want a good place to eat you should stop here.
Raqs P.
Place rating: 5 CA, CA
PiZza incomparable to California thick crust pizzas. There are no skimping on cheese or ingredients! Amazing!
Sean M.
Place rating: 5 Plano, TX
WOW… after reading all the great reviews… I’m like. really… Well the truth is. REALLY. what a great place. App’s were awesome, Pizza was incredible, service was stupendious.
Nancy C.
Place rating: 3 Tahlequah, OK
Sam and Ellas is a pizza place located in downtown Tahlequah. Their food is outstanding. I love the food but I can only enjoy it if I call in an order and take it to go. The service is a little hit and miss and I feel that they have a high turnover rate. It doesn’t help that the staff all appear to be under the age of 25 with noone managing them. Aside from that and the prices of their pizza I’d recommend it… But call it in.
Laura L.
Place rating: 4 Stilwell, OK
Pizza place with Chicken motif. But Mom chose the side salad and yard bird. I ordered the Chicken salad. Coke products(sad face). Good atmosphere, good music. This is a set down place.
Tom H.
Place rating: 5 Oklahoma City, OK
Killa pizza! Just had pizza and it was perfect. We will be back when in the area. You cannot go wrong here. This is the real deal!
Ripley L.
Place rating: 5 Mansfield, TX
Best pizza ever, EVER!!! My daughter said it was good she was wrong! Best I have ever had anywhere. You must try if you get within 50 miles of Tahlequah OK.
Dan L.
Place rating: 5 Wichita, KS
Had the meatza pizza. OMG! This pizza is the bomb! Tastes great… airy and chewy crust with a crunch. I don’t know how they do it… but it’s amazing! My first time… I’ll be back!
Tara C.
Place rating: 5 Fayetteville, AR
Some of the best pizza I’ve had! I got the Big & Sloppy pizza but added bell pepper instead of black olives. This pizza was enormous! I brought half of it home and it reheated nicely for breakfast the next morning! Great downtown location, fun country atmosphere, excellent pizza! Stop if you’re in the area!
Jennifer W.
Place rating: 5 Collinsville, OK
If you happen to be in Tahlequah then eat at Sam and Ella’s(sounds like salmonella) it has to be the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. We tried the ArtiWrap which was just ooey gooey cheesy goodness. I had the dill pickle pie which sound nasty but was delicious with chicken, dill pickles, cheese and a creamy ranch base. The atmosphere is a little cheesy with all the chickens but there is a large spatula with the name Carrie on it. Carrie Underwood worked here before she made it big so that’s a fun fact. They are a little slow but if you’re sitting around visiting with friends or family and have time to wait you won’t be disappointed in these magnificent pizza pies!