Wise Pies Pizza and Subs

Wise Pies is my favorite pizza spot in town. I reccomend it to anyone who is from out of town and is looking for a local pizza spot. The owners are great and the pizza is awesome! Honestly, I’ve never even tried anything else on the menu — always order a pizza and never the «by-​the-​slice» option that they order — the fresh pizza is perfect!
Breadsticks are bland — don’t bother.

Cute restaurant, quaint. Ordered a veggie pizza and breadsticks. Both were pretty good. Friendly staff. Have been here many times, and it never disappoints.

I tried Wise Pies when some friends came to visit who are serious pizza aficionados. First came out the wilted slimy salads. Bad start. Then we were served the blandest, most boring bread sticks I’ve ever tasted. They were accompanied by nacho cheese sauce from a can. Gross. I’ve read great reviews of this place so I was willing to ignore the disappointing sides if the pizza lived up to the hype. It didn’t. Not at all. It was dry, bland, and had almost nothing on it. We were so disappointed that we left half the pizza on the table, got in the car, and drove to a different pizza restaurant where we knew we could get a descent pizza.
I have had real New York City pizza. This isn’t even close.

I’ve ate here a couple times and it has never blown me away! Some day I hope that changes but until then I will still eat here occasionally!

Not bad, but not great pizza. Came here on a Friday night with my son and had a nice time. The people are very nice and the service was good. The place was clean and a typical pizza joint. We ordered a sausage and mushroom pizza that took a normal amount of time to get onto our table. The breadsticks were bland but edible, and the pizza was good. I think it’s the dough that keeps this place from being great. The crust has a good chew to it, but the taste is bland as though something is missing.
We’ll come back again sometime. This place is just good enough to give a thumbs up and keep us coming back.

I have the best luck with this place during optimal lunch time, when their by-​the-​slice-​pizzas are still pretty fresh. They have some nice combo deals that include a drink. The Carnivore is delicious, and my BFF frequently gets the White Pizza. It’s especially nice to sit outside when the weather is nice and enjoy some pizza for lunch. They recently opened a second location (at 3^rd and Margaret) which I’ve yet to check out.

Best pizza in Terre Haute hands down! I am a huge fan of unique specialty pizzas. There seems to be no other pizza place in Terre Haute that has a comparable selection of gourmet specialty pizzas. My recommendation to you is to come here with a friend and order an 18″ pizza. Their pizza is best had when made to order. I have had the slices that they leave out and it’s just not as good. I was quite surprised to find such delicious NY style pizza here. My only gripe with their food is the mediocre breadsticks. I wouldn’t bother with those.
Among other considerations, this place has a fairly nice ambiance/​character to it as well. The only let down is the unfriendly service. The employees just don’t seem satisfied working here. Hopefully that changes sometime. Nevertheless, this is a Terre Haute gem which is why I gave it 5 stars.

Love their pizza! Great crust and fresh toppings and pretty reasonably priced. However, only 3 stars because I had the worst breadsticks and cheese sauce I’ve ever experienced here. Hard as a rock with no seasoning at all.

Wise Pies serves New York-​style pizza in Terre Haute, Indiana They’ll certainly make your choice of pizza from scratch, but I took advantage of their premade pizza by-​the-​slice option. If I had more time, I wouldn’t have done this because I’ve seen the reheating of these slices negatively affect the consistency of the crust at many other places. However, I was happy with how the crust remained fairly soft and somewhat chewy on my pepperoni and carnivore (ham, sausage, and pepperoni) slices from Wise Pies. The sauce was pretty good and the cheese was okay, but there was not a lot of either of them on the pizza. The best part of both slices was probably the flavorful meat.
Wise Pies Pizza & Subs has a couple locations in Terre Haute, and I went to the downtown one — close to Indiana State University’s campus. This location has a fair amount of room to eat in, and they do offer some bottled beer as well. I don’t believe they offer delivery, but it is worth trying carryout or dine-​in at Wise Pies.

DON’T WASTE YOUR TIME! If I could not give them a star I would. They’re great pizza doesn’t make up for their terrible service and customer treatment. They will manipulate you and not help new customers out. Literally the worst service I’ve ever had from a «family owned» business. I would avoid this place like the plague.

Nice, thin, and crispy!

I enjoyed a date with my wife here on Friday night about 6pm. I was afraid it would be crowded during the prime dining hours, but there were only a few other tables that were occupied. During our dinner 3 – 4 other people stopped in for carry out. Parking is ample in the bank’s parking lot across the street. Then again, we were not there during the banks operating hours so their lot was empty. There is parking right on the street though.
The staff was friendly and helpful in ordering as it was our first time. We went with a small order of breadsticks (made fresh daily!) and a 14″ Caesar, Please. Seating outside was very pleasant. They had a covered patio and the picture-​perfect weaher topped it off.
The food was brought out within a reasonable time. It’s a fairly casual joint with paper plates and styrofoam cups. I could tell the breadsticks were fresh (as advertised). However there wasn’t anything too spectacular about them. Perhaps some special sauce, seasoning, spices, etc. could really help with making them more of a buzz. The pizza was not the best I’ve had, but it was pretty good. (After living in the Chicago area for years… I’ve had my share of ridiculously good pizza.) The word that keeps coming to mind is «good.» The sauce, dough, and toppings… we’re good, but not great. I wished for more toppings, as it seemed an little sparse.
Wifey and I finished off the 14″ pie and it seemed just the right amount for us. The atmosphere was very laid back and we lingered and talked for a long time. We left feeling full, but not sick or greasy. I wrestled between the 3 and 4 star rating but settled with 3. Overall we had a good experience and will possibly visit again sometime in the future.

Pizza was really good, I like thin crust (I’m from New York) it was very easy to handle as we were driving. I ordered a turkey sub and got a turkey and bacon sandwich no dressing, but was pretty good. We went to the new one on 3^rd street. I thought the cost was a little. pricey for what we got. I did like the brick and mortar it looks like they converted an old gas station which is a really good look, and they have a couple of church pews for to go customers pretty neat.

I think that in terms of variety, Wise Pies is great. I dig being able to try different toppings on pizzas, especially when the toppings are fresh. However, I don’t think the overall pizza quality itself is necessarily that great. It’s ok and definitely not terrible, but I wouldn’t really call it the best pizza in TH.

Thin crunchy crust, good tomato sauce and fresh toppings. What’s not to like?

Buffalo chicken sub actually has some taste. Thank you! Nice lunch time atmosphere. Staff is friendly. Prices are on the money. I’ll be back.

Yummy!
Being a New Yorker, this pizza reminds me of home.
Very tasty pizza. Great staff and fast service.

Wise Pies, supposedly the best pizza in Terre Haute land offers decent thin-​sliced pizza with good topping options. Not the best, not the worst in the land of pizza, but really decent if you’re in the mood. We had the Hawaiian and the Meat Lovers. Both were good. Not greasy. Came a little cold for my taste (unless I’d been enjoying it the following morning — smile -), but was fine.

Nice local shop with sandwiches and pizza by the slice. Introverted but friendly service. Had a good experience here the sandwiches and pizza were very good.

Excellent! I was super impressed not only by the quality of food but the décor and ambiance is fun and clean. The calzone was delish!!! I am all about supporting locally owned restaurants.