I keep trying to love this place but it always turns out to be just OK overall. Some things are wonderful and some items are terrible. For example, the meatball hoagie and the BBQ beef are superb, however, the burger should be avoided at all cost and the teriyaki wings are a salty mess. I’m not sure how they can do some items so well, and others not well at all.
Sean S.
Place rating: 1 Bassett, WI
I don’t understand these people given five stares they must no them cause I went n got a large sasuge n pepperoni and it sucked badly any toppings under cooked first n last time I go
Gary V.
Place rating: 5 Geneva, IL
Well worth the drive from Lake Geneva. This is a small place, but it has great pizza. Prices are good as well.
Stephen B.
Place rating: 4 Chicago, IL
The pizza is definitely square! I usually mix it up between the local pizza pickup locations in town and Squared is one of my favorites. The crust is quite dense and thick on the tossed style, something you may have to have a big appetite(or a couple friends) to conquer. Generous with ingredients, sauce, and cheese, Squared is worth a try when you’re in town. Specialty item: Squared offers a «stuffed» pizza. This is basically two pizzas melted into one. It’s a monster!
Lisa C.
Place rating: 5 Richmond, IL
I grew up in Chicago where pizza is a staple in your diet. We’ve lived out here for 4 years and have not been able to find a pizza place that was worth reviewing, until now. We ordered a sausage and mushroom stuffed pizza an I can honestly say it was amazing. I will recommend this place to all of our friends and family.
David B.
Place rating: 4 Lake Geneva, WI
Ordered a pizza for the fam and was not disappointed by the quality. Nice to have some hometown pizza be the better option available.
Melissa W.
Place rating: 5 Burlington, WI
Took extended family there. No one was disappointed. All fresh and yummy ingredients. And the crust is fantastic. They have some really good daily specials too.
Doug K.
Place rating: 5 Wonder Lake, IL
they make a mean banana split sundae. Three scoops of creamy delicious ice cream And all the fixings! Can’t wait to try the pizza
Amy L.
Place rating: 5 Twin Lakes, WI
Woo Hoo! Finally a good pizza place locally!!! Located in the old Lancelot Pizza location. Bonus, they DELIVER!!!
Linda M.
Place rating: 5 Twin Lakes, WI
Love the pizza and the wings. We now have great pizza in our town. Please support so they can stay and succeed.