Elizabeth’s Bakery

Great local bakery! Always has something yummy to pick up for dessert or a special occasion. Birthday cakes, cupcakes, cookies and breads never disappoint.

Old Birthday cake does not make a tres leches. Always so disappointing when I come here. Not even sure what their specialty is as nothing looks special. They should embrace the Mexican culture in the the community and make the classics.

Awesome value — $ 40 for a beautiful custom cake, that is elegant and tasteful. The cake itself was absolutely delicious, the frosting and filling sweet and plenty of it too. I was so satisified — customer service was great too as they called me and stayed later bc I had forgotten about my pick up time. Much better service than the pricey cake place in town that never calls people back and has hours that only work with their schedules. I’d definitely Order a cake from here again. Pastries and breads are also amazing.

The best bakery in the world. The girls that work there are very friendly and the cakes and pastries are delicious! ¹⁰⁄₁₀

Decent pastries. Friendly service.

i was here later in the day and the cases were pretty empty which is a good sign. fresh baked goods that people like sell out! the breads all looked very good but i had a cinnamon twist and it was ok. prices were reasonable and the guy behind the counter was friendly. some of the baked goods were more unique ethnic items that i wasnt familiar with.
i had no idea this place existed until i had to stop in the bank of america and saw this in the parking lot behind the BOA. worth checking out, probably the earlier you get there the better luck you will have!

This is my mom’s favorite bakery, and there have been days when my mom goes to pick up a bunch of delicious baked goods (rolls, cake, pastries), and my dad goes out the same morning to get the same things to surprise my mom. (These are the best days ever.) Most recently, my parents ordered my birthday cake from Elizabeth’s, and it might have been the best cake I’ve ever had. The thing was gigantic — it took up a good chunk of a picnic table, and I look pretty tiny behind it in my obligatory birthday cake pictures. They let my parents order the cake with two different flavors — half chocolate cake with strawberry filling, and half vanilla cake with pineapple filling — and frosted the whole thing with a whipped buttercream frosting. It was fantastic. The cake was moist and sweet without being too sweet, the fillings were delicious and well made, and the frosting was perfect. Everything we’ve ever had from Elizabeth’s has been great — from the hard rolls to cookies to cupcakes. I’m daydreaming about it all as I write this review.
I just decided that I’m going to eat some of that leftover birthday cake for breakfast.

Great bakery. I’ve only had bread and hard rolls from here, but they are awesome! And the prices really are great!

A little goes a long way here.
Don’t be fooled by the prices, as I was when I first came in. Their hard rolls, cookies, and other baked goods are as good as the next place you’ll find, for a fraction of the price.
A dozen hard rolls for $ 4.50? It’s like I stepped into the 1980’s. Where else could you find these prices?
For comparison, Franks Bakery in Wallingford charges $ 9 for a dozen. Double the price!
And the rolls are just as good at Elizabeth’s. A little more on the softer side, but they’re delicious. Want one of those huge deli cookies with sprinkles to go along with your lunch? One dollar.
Admittedly, price isn’t the only determining factor when considering future visits, but the quality here is top notch. I’ll surely be coming back.

This bakery used to be called Jill’s New York Bakery. I ordered a cake here for my birthday. The cake was excellent! I ordered a white cake with whipped cream frosting. In the center of the cake was fresh strawberries and whipped cream frosting. The cake was moist and flavorful. The whipped cream frosting was light, yet it had a great flavor to it. The cake was decorated beautifully too with big pink flowers and tiny small flowers with leaves. These were made out of a sweeter frosting and it was delicious. Price was good too. I ordered a 9 in cake for $ 20. I would definitely order another cake from here. I also had a cupcake from here with the sweeter frosting. Again, moist and flavorful cake. I also had challah bread from here. It was moist, but I thought it could have had more flavor to it. Also, I asked them to cut it since I was using it for french toast and the machine cut it too thin. I still love this bakery. Can’t wait to order my next cake from here.