Went above and beyond. I called to make a delivery order. Based on where I was staying(3.2 miles) we were out of the delivery zone.(??) Dave didn’t even hesitate to see if he could figure something out. Within a minute, he took my order and said, «No problem, we should be there in 45 minutes.» Within the stated time, a large Old School Classic, no peppers, added tomatoes was delivered. Good pizza. Thin crust, perfect amount of toppings on every slice.
Jen C.
Place rating: 5 Shrewsbury, MA
Had the Giuseppe Sicilian pizza and it was great! The crust was so fluffy. And the slices are huge! Great place
Howard G.
Place rating: 5 Boston, MA
Best pizza in Wellesley. Sauce is excellent and the crust is light and airy. Overall the perfect combination. Love the atmosphere with tons of sports memorabilia. Parking can be tight as its on the main strip in Wellesley.
Sam D.
Place rating: 1 Boston, MA
There was an insect in my salad. Aside from that, the salad was very good.
Swathi T.
Place rating: 4 Burlington, MA
Love the buffalo chicken pizza. I normally prefer chicken when I am eating out but tried the marinara Pizza for the first time and I just loved it.
Matt K.
Place rating: 5 Chicopee, MA
I ordered a new school pizza(buff chicken), mozz sticks, and a cannoli. This place is great. The crust has that nice Neapolitan quality. The chicken was nice grilled pieces, no breading. Really good quality ingredients. I would take a picture but I ate the pizza before leaving this review. I’m from the other side of the state and here on business, I’ll be ordering from then every time I come back.
Fantasia A.
Place rating: 2 Providence, RI
The closing time for Sunday is NOT9 it’s 8. Don’t make the mistake of going at 7:40 like we did, thinking we had plenty of time. The blatant looks and attitude we received from the man at the register was just unnecessary. If you are closing at 8 then just say it and either tell us sorry we can’t take your order or just take the order and expect that you still have 20 mins to do so. You might also want to adjust your hours on Unilocal.We were not the only ones as people were still calling them requesting to put in orders. It was just the experience that rubbed us the wrong way. Pizza it self is pretty good compared to the other places in the area. Unfortunately, that experience has left us with a bad taste.
Brandon K.
Place rating: 5 Westwood, MA
Visited the Old School Italian Pizzeria, today 9÷26÷15. It’s next door to Yogurtology and is Definitely old school. Which I really like. Modern places are nice too, but sometimes old fashioned places are better, and more known throughout a community. The staff here were all very friendly and you can see them making pizzas from the counter, which is really cool and more of an «old school» thing. The pizza I got was delicious and very italian as advertised… much better than Papa Gino’s or other chains. In Wellesley Center, on Route 135, near the Route 16 intersection. 5 stars… Highly suggested.
Steve W.
Place rating: 5 Boston, MA
By far the best pizza. Just the right amount of ingredients. Perfect crust. Friendly service.
Nikos L.
Place rating: 4 Wellesley, MA
5 Stars in Wellesley. Best Pizza in town, and I have tried them all. Price & Delivery are reasonable too. Keep up the great work Old School!
K S.
Place rating: 5 Dedham, MA
Delicious pizza with great crust that’s firm but not too chewy. They called us back to re confirm our order to make sure it was correct. Great customer service.
Cole H.
Place rating: 1 Los Gatos, CA
So I ordered a small pizza and a chinese chicken salad with caesar dressing. The reason the chicken part was so important is that my friend is allergic to tuna and cannot eat it. After an ungodly 50 minutes of waiting, what should appear on top of the salad? Tuna. I didn’t even know that tuna was an option! The pizza was okay, but did not justify the wait time. By the time we called to ask for a new salad, they had closed and refused to deal with us until the morning. And who wants a salad first thing in the morning?
Ina K.
Place rating: 5 Boston, MA
Amazing pizza and amazing wings. The pizza slices are huge, and it taste like it has been cooked with a bit of care. The wings here are the best wings in the Greater Boston Area. The food here can fill you up quick! Def worth the time and money. You can’t go wrong with this place
R P.
Place rating: 4 Brunswick, GA
This high end pizza point offers American style and small rectangular thick crust pizza(made from the same dough). Topping are fresh and plentiful. The staff and pleasant, congeneal and efficient. Regular menu of sandwiches and dinners. The place is small and pleasantly appointed. For a local pizza shop it’s great.
Isabella L.
Place rating: 5 Newton, MA
Was looking for a place to have a quick bite before a concert I was attending and stumbled upon this place. I had never been here before even though I frequently am in Wellesley but I had heard about it. The décor is awesome. Posters of sports legends to Marilyn Monroe, signed football jerseys, and leg lamps. Real neat place. The menu is mostly pizza but they also have subs and the like. I got an Italian sub which was delicious. I wish I could have had enough time to order a pizza! Will be back
Bryan L.
Place rating: 5 Clinton, MA
Ridiculously good pizza! I’m a hardcore pizza snob and their pepperoni is on point. The sauce isn’t overpowering the crust is thin and crunchy and the cheese is legit. If you’re looking for pizza that exceeds your expectations look no further.
Yara F.
Place rating: 4 Wellesley Hills, MA
Staff is friendly, pizza is yummy, décor is super fun and hip. Good for a quick bite, but not extremely fancy food overall. It is a little pricey at times, but the portions are pretty good and my experience with the food has been usually pretty fresh. It’s in a good location in town, parking at the library across the street is cheap so it’s easy to get to. This place gets really busy around school closing time, so plan accordingly so you aren’t in a sea of middle school aged kids!
Alexis C.
Place rating: 3 Wellesley, MA
I went in here to grab a bite to eat during a break from the studying at the library. The service was pretty quick and the cashier and cooks were friendly. The pizza was pretty good, but I was most impressed by the crust of the pizza which was very thin and doughy. The atmosphere was very laid back and there were lots of decorations on the walls were definitely old school. I would definitely go back to eat here if it was convenient but I wasn’t so impressed that I would go out of my way to go back.
Dave M.
Place rating: 5 Cypress, CA
With the caveat that I’m from California, and therefore an unschooled barbarian on such matters, this place is quintessential Boston Italian. We had the Mac and cheese bites(where have they been all my life?) and eggplant Parmesan sandwich. A perfect combo of you’re a vegetarian who wants to calorie binge. Great food, great décor, and a welcome relief from the uppity Beverly Hills vibe you get from much of the town of Wellesley. Best of all, there was a ban on tap water at the time we visited(over-reaction to an ecoli scare) so these guys comped us a bottle of H2O. Cool.
David K.
Place rating: 5 Framingham, MA
A while ago I noticed this place as I drove by. I thought it looked nice. Later, I asked my friends who live in Wellesley, and both said they thought the pizza was awful. I thought that was a shame, and remembered that North End and Wellesley Hills both had great pizza, so that was enough. Yesterday, I was in the area, and thought I’d give it a try. Well, I wasn’t in the mood for pizza, and their pizza looked dry and I did not want to risk it, so I had the Greek Salad Wrap. While I waited, I checked out the Boston Bruins memorabilia. Pretty cool. It was AMAZING. It came quickly, the server was very nice, and the price was fine. It was wrapped well, and was the most delicious greek salad wrap I’ve ever had. Crunchy, beautiful, not too messy, and very filling. Maybe, in the winter, I will try their pizza.