Miceli Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant

Unilocal should give us the option of giving no star. I’ve given this place chance after chance. No more for me. The last time I ordered from here, I got two pepperoni slices and a chicken bacon ranch salad. The guy on the phone told me 20 minutes. I get there in 30 minutes. Food of course isn’t ready. I had to wait another 35 minutes before my food was ready. This isn’t the first time that this is happened either. Their food is also never consistent. I found a new local pizza joint to go to and OMG, their pizzas are effing amazing (Giovanni’s — right across the street from this place).

Penne All Vodka Slice = Wow! Amazing. leaves you craving more and more… I can still taste it now

If I could give it no stars I would. Having ordered from this pizzeria many many times in the past, my gf and I placed our delivery order and asked for the Fra Diavolo Pizza. It was supposed to have marinara, fresh mozz, crumbled sausage and cherry peppers. We asked for it well done and crispy. What we got was so undercooked you couldn’t even pick it up. There was barely any toppings either other than way too much cheese. It was by far the worst pizza I have ever had delivered. So i called to complain and the owner says to me «what do you want me to do?»… Uuumm I paid $ 22 so bake another one properly? 29 minutes later I get another pizza that was also NOT COOKED and completely inedible. I asked the delivery guy for a refund and he called the boss.
The boss/​owner told him bring the pies back and DON’T refund me. REALLY???
You know I grabbed those pies, got in the car and headed over. I was barely in the door and keeping my cool when the owner came out and got in my face and said he’s not refunding. I was like ok this pizza is not cooked and inedible. He again said he made me two pies and he’s not giving my money back. How pathetic. I had to tell him just give me my money and you’ll never see me again. After a brief argument he gave me the $ 22 less the tax. I said hey it’s $ 22 plus tax. He told me I was lucky to get anything back at all.
The owner was totally wrong, rude, disrespectful and should have acted like a grown man.
I have never had this kind of a problem anywhere so this was definitely a first. And now definitely a last!!!
My only regret was not taking a picture to show all of you Unilocalers just how awful the pizza was. I am a chef by trade and I know how to cook a pizza so I’ll be doing it at home from now on.

Came for lunch with two coworkers because one of my friends lives near by and this is their pizza place they always go to.
Speciality slices today included: bacon pineapple, Sicilian, grandma vodka, white, baked ziti, buffalo chicken, chicken marsala, BBQ chicken, chicken bacon ranch, pepperoni & sausage I think that’s it? I tried to remember all of them ! They also had large garlic knots, pinwheels, rice balls, stuffed pizza, and beef patties (odd).
Pizza: Most slices have a sesame seed crust so if you’re not into that, I wouldn’t come here.
Chicken Marsala slice: lame, not really good at all. The flavor/​seasoning was so weak it barely tasted like Marsala wine/​sauce at all.
Grandma vodka: great little slice, tasty vodka sauce with fresh mozzarella on a crispy crust. Downside was this is a fairly small slice for $ 4.
White slice: if you love a lot of ricotta this is your slice. The whole slice was spread full of ricotta and mozzarella cheese sprinkled with basil. Good slice, but similar to most pizza places.
Chicken bacon ranch: this slice had the most flavor. If you’re looking for a filling slice go for this one. Crumbled bacon, mozzarella & cheddar cheese, chicken bits, and ranch. I mean all of those ingredients are good alone so of course together they are delicious. (This slice does not have a sesame crust)
Overall: their pizza isn’t that memorable compared to other pizzerias I’ve been to. Slices are $ 4 and slightly smaller than other pizzerias. Go for the vodka & chicken bacon ranch.

The absolute best pizza I have ever had on Long Island. Grandma aka vodka pizza is a must when you go. Everyone who works here is so friendly. Excited to have found this place so close to my house.

Had the buffalo chicken and vodka sauce with cheese pizza. They were phenomenal.

I didn’t care for this pizzeria. When I called up to place my order it was fine. But when we got our pizza it was awful. It was missing ingredients and tasted plain. They put no seasonings on the pizza. I called them up to complain and the owner was rude to me. They don’t have good pizza & the owner is not professional. I do not recommend Miceli Brothers pizza. I will not eat here again.

The Chicken Scaparella is amazing, there is over 100 different gourmet pizzas. Pasta night is an amazing bargain, only $ 10.95 and they give us bread, salad, coffee and dessert. I personally recommend the Margherita pizza, fresh mozzarella, tomato and basil, it is perfect. Even better the grandma ala vodka is a must try. Just about everything is absolutely perfect.

I rarely give 5 start reviews so here it goes…
This pizzeria/​restaurant is AMAZING! I went there for the first time yesterday with my boyfriend for dinner. My friend suggested it to me since she went there for an event a few weeks ago and said the pizza was delicious. I asked the chef what the specials were and he suggested the Veal with prosciutto and melted mozzarella in sherry wine. It sounded delicious so I tried it and… OMG. Amazing! So mouthwatering and fresh. My boyfriend had the buffalo pizza and regular slice and he said it tasted like authentic NYC pizza… maybe better! The owners are really friendly– they had us cracking up laughing! Also, you can’t beat the prices. I would DEFINITELY recommend Miceli’s to anyone who is looking for a delicious and affordable meal!!!

Local pizza got nothin’ on Miceli! This is the best slice around! Ol’ boy is always in there making things fresh. Grandma slice is killer.
Dare to try vodka pie for a very decadent treat… He’s got something really special there!

Today was my first visit to this fabulous pizza place and our food was amazing! The price was good too!

Former Fontanas pizza, love the pizzan large pieces and very cheese and sauce is great

First time customer, definitely will be back. Ordered the shrimp parmigiana hero. Food is very fresh and high quality. The waitress brought us freshly baked Italian bread with butter. She was really helpful in describing the menu options. Warm and cozy, exactly what I want in a restaurant. Will recommend this to anyone in the West Babylon area.

I had both the regular and Sicilian pizza and they were both solid. The crust is crunchy and the sauce is good. The restaurant is nothing special but its a good place to grab a couple of slices.

Well I take it back, it seems every time I come in here they have a serious hand washing problem. I see the owner or his son scratch their nose or face and touch pizza. I don’t think I’ll be back.

Fresh ingredients, good prices. Nice variety too. they always have interesting pizzas for the slice, pinwheels and calzones.

I just had a slice of Pizza it was good and the staff was very Polite I will come back and try something esle.

My go to for the best NY pizza when I’m in town. Family run business, includes a restaurant and counter service in two separate rooms.
Probably one of the most varied selection of slices on the island, including salad style pizza, thick slices and sicilian/​grandma varieties. The sesame seed crust on some of the slices offers a surprisingly good mouth feel and texture — don’t knock it til you try it. I always get it on a pie when I place an order. Recommend the vodka sauce slice, buffalo chicken and the Caesar salad slice.
Rolls and pinwheels are pretty good as well. Restaurant side offers good specials every day (follow on their Facebook page), and offers a good space for larger parties.

Ummm… no thanks, ill stick to café Gio. Went here on NYE to pick up 2 pasta entrees. I went there thirty min after I called. When I got there, it wasn’t ready, and they said it would b right out… thirty minutes pass… finally got food but they forgot my garlic knots! They r lucky I realized before I got home!!!
Also they aren’t too sanitary… guy wiped his nose while plating pizzas. And the guy making the pizzas was also on the register and he didn’t wash his hands. Ewwwww only good thing was their garlic knots were banging.

I like to pizza and heroes very good