We have been ordering delivery from Pizza Station for years and even recommended it to neighbors. I ordered the other day $ 136 order and tipped $ 30 for the delivery, I just tried to order now and they told me I’m out of their delivery area. We live only 6.4 miles away. There was no other explanation. I didn’t know 6 mi was too far for a delivery.
P H.
Place rating: 2 Budd Lake, NJ
Dear Pizza Station, I really, really want to like you more. Your prices are good and you’re close by. When I dine in, your counter help is always VERY polite and welcoming. You have GALAGA! I’ve eaten in a dozen times and for $ 5, it can’t be beat. However, we ordered a take out for a group of us in the office the other day and it was horrid. Half of us had the Chix Parm sub and it was rubbery and gross. No plates, napkins, cutlery etc was offered or delivered, we were told you get it if you ask. Just some advice, if folks order salads, offer forks, plates and napkins. C’mon. Your delivery time is quick though.
Mark S.
Place rating: 3 Haledon, NJ
The poor condition of the parking lot and the lack of cars are not inviting signs. I came here for the first time on a Saturday afternoon at 5pm. There wasn’t much foot traffic but the phones were ringing when I was there. It’s your basic pizza joint with maybe nine pizzas to choose slices from plus sandwiches and other food items available. In comparison to the parking area, the place wasn’t sparkling but it was clean although small. I ate two slices of Sicilian while watching part of the Rutgers football game. The slices could had used some more time in the oven as I got them very quickly. When I left, I continued to make my 20 minute U-turn on Route 23 since the place is literally in the middle of the highway.
Preston T.
Place rating: 2 OAK RIDGE, NJ
When I first came to Oak Ridge, My wife and I absolutely loved Pizza Station. Unfortunately, the time before last, the pie was an hour late getting to our home. Giving them the benefit of the doubt, we decided to try it again. The person who answered the phone this last time was rude, didn’t get our order correct, and hung up before giving us the cost of the pie. Six months ago, I would have recommended Pizza Station, however due to the drop in service, I will not.
Joe K.
Place rating: 4 Oak Ridge, NJ
Best pizza in town(depending on what you call town in these parts…), HUGE portions of good food(always come home with food). Sandwiches are the best in town as well. This is the kind of place you can relax, eat well, and enjoy. Just note that the map is WAY off… this is in the Oak Ridge section of W. Milford, no where near«downtown»(misnomer) or Bubbling Springs.
Mark P.
Place rating: 3 Oak Ridge, NJ
Good pizza, good wings and good service. In an area with tons of pizza joints, I used to travel a bit further for Pizza Station. Their pizza was consistently good, the wings are pretty decent and the sandwiches were also good.