Broadway Pizzeria & Restaurant

The best pizza in the area, they have really delicious and creative pizzas. Some of my favorites are the eggplant rollatini and white with spinach. I won’t give them 5 stars because they started charging for cups of sauce, which is ridiculous. Also the owner or manager, I don’t know what her position is, she’s someone important there, isn’t very friendly. Regardless they have great food so I will go back, but they really need to reevaluate charging for tiny cups of red sauce.

The Chicken Caeser Salad pizza here is the absolute BEST. Most pizza place around here just literally plop a salad on an empty crust (where’s the love?). Here, there’s actual cheese baked INTO the crust, with salad on top.

Definitely one of the best pizza shops in Westwood. New York style pizza, and a bunch of specialties.

Broadway Pizza should probably not steal Big Daddy’s in Hillsdale, garlic knot slider idea. Come up with your own stuff!!! Tacky

Burned garlic knots and a meat lovers pizza with whole slices of ham just slapped on top. Tried to pick up a slice and the crust pulled away from the rest of the slice entirely — it broke in TWO. All of this was what we waited an HOUR AND A HALF for… and the place is a mile (at most) down the road from us. The SAME ROAD we live on… so how did the delivery driver get so lost he had to call for directions — more than once??? When we called to complain about the atrocious service plus the poor quality of food the owner said «what do you want me to do about that?» Wow… NEVER again

Best Gluten-​free tasting pizza in the area. It is more expensive but def worth it!

I moved to Hillsdale early this year. A Neighbor told me they had the best Hawaiian Pizza. They weren’t lying. Hes got his own twist on it and It was awsome. The slices behind glass all looked great too. Looking forward to many more Hawaiians.

we haven’t been here to eat in a while, but we used to be semi-​regulars when we lived in the area. one night we were out shopping and decided to just grab a quick slice of pizza, not knowing that there was restaurant seating in the back room. we opted to grab some food instead, and it was fantastic. the guy who served us remembered anyone who had been there before (recognizing us and remembering what we ordered the second time we were there), and was extremely friendly. the food was also terrific. after we had tried some of our favorite italian meals there, we just started asking for recommendations. based on things we had already tried, he led us to some other fantastic meals we never would have thought to even try. i only wish we lived closer, so we could eat there like we used to.

Went here the other day for a quick slice of pizza and its still as good as I remember. I use to come here all the time in highschool, and just was feeling a specialty slice after shopping at kmart. I got the baked ziti slice along with a rootbeer and it came to about eight bucks. Let me tell you though, as a guy who always orders two slices, one was enough. It was cooked well, and the guy even brought it over to me because I was distracted by a game on my phone. Not sure why this place has bad reviews, but ive heard of people complaining about the prices. Well welcome to Bergen County every freaking thing here is overpriced.

I went there today with my two kids. I had purchased a
coupon & wanted to use it. The first time we were looking to sit in the restaurant section in the back. It is BYOB so my husband & I were looking to bring a bottle of wine but unfortunately we went on a Sunday & the back was closed so we chose another restaurant in the area. I went back on a Tuesday afternoon & the restaurant part was again not open. There are some booths in the front area but it is moreover a pizza joint up front. I can tell you the food was pretty darn good. Garlic knots were great, the Broadway salad with artichokes & Motz cheese was great. I ordered the creamy Italian & balsamic dressing on the side, both that they make there. They were terrific!!! The cheese pizza was EXCELLENT. Crust was not too thick, just crispy enough & the sauce & cheese were perfect! The only negative on the food was the cavatelli we ordered was way over cooked! Kind of mushy. It had potential if it was cooked properly. We live two towns away but the kids loved the food & I would probably go back as a family if the back area were open so we could enjoy a little more ambiance & some wine.

Great deli. Good quality and service.

Broadway Pizzeria is my family’s favorite pizza place and Italian dinner spot. We have been coming to Broadway for 20+ years. There is nothing better than walking into a restaurant and being greeted with smiles. This is exactly what we get when we enter Broadway because we have grown up here!
The service is excellent. The pizza is to die for (your typical NJ NY pizza). The prices are average for the area.
What is even better is they have an Italian restaurant in the back. Their pastas and entrees like their pizza are to die for. It is also a BYO. My family literally has so many great memories at this little pizzeria and restaurant. Now that my siblings and I are grown adults and we do not go out to eat as a family as much as we used to, there is nothing better than getting that text from our mom to meet her at Broadway for a family dinner. We literally live for it!

I would recommend Broadway in Westwood to anybody looking for noticeably overpriced pizza with thick unappealing crust, below average Italian food, or a generally surly staff; particularly the owners. Has consistently had higher prices than all neighboring competitors despite sub par product. Otherwise, I would suggest going to any of the other better/​cheaper/​nicer/​less crusty places in the area.

I was disappointed to find that things haven’t changed and the pies are still lacking. It’s all about the crust and this one just misses the mark by a mile. It’s almost as though there is a ingredient missing, salt or something it’s as bland as cardboard. I am shocked that anyone would continue to buy their pizza here with SO many other shops within minutes drive. Seriously Jodi, if you read this PLEASE focus on the crust you guys used to be head and shoulders above the competition.

The sausage pie is better than average. They are usually generous with the toppings. When I need a pie delivered, so far this is my go to place.

Huge slices, delicious garlic knots, not always the friendliest behind the counter.

Broadway Pizza is truly a hidden gem. The food, whether you order a pizza in the front or a special from the dining area in the back, is excellent. The service as well, run by and/​or supervised by «Uncle Tony» is just one more reason to go. I would give Broadway six stars if I could!
Portions are huge, BYOB, try the garlic knots.

We have been coming here for Friday dinners for several years. They serve pizza, sandwiches etc. up front. In the back is a small d/​r with a few booths & tables for 2 which can be joined for 6. The pizza is very good, thin crust, well seasoned sauce. It is our favorite take out pizza. This is not a dressy place, but your neighborhood place to come for good inexpensive food. BYO
The entrees served in the d/​r are very good standard Italian. What makes it worth coming for are the specials, most of which are created by the owner’s Uncle Tony who is the waiter. Some favorites are eggplant rolatini stuffed with ground sausage, spinach & ricotta, bowtie pasta with toasted pine nuts, chicken in a sherry cream sauce and grilled chicken over rotelli & arugula in a lemon cream sauce.
Good value, good pizza & good Italian food.