Yogurtini Self Serve

Nice clean frozen yogurt bar. Friendly staff person. Other than that, it’s your average run of the mill frozen yogurt. Bland and artificially flavored. Some flavors are just nasty. These places are all the same. It’s the fixings that improve the quality of taste. If you want ice cream. Go to a real ice cream shop. There is one just north of outlets on the east side of rt. 60. I forgot the name sorry.

This is hands down our favorite yogurt place in Williamsburg! We can always find easy parking. Great location with movies, shops and restaurants within walking distance.
There flavors are unique and delicious. Vegan, non-​fat options always available. 76 topping options which my son likes to confirm every time!
Service is laid back. Facilities always clean. And bonus a great outdoor seating area.
I love the décor too — industrial look with teal and glass accents. Very comfortable booths inside! Can’t say enough good things!

Not impressed! The first time I visited the store the yogurt I purchased tasted spoiled! Yuck! I wanted to give the shop another chance so we went today (4 months later) and took the kids. I had a coupon and figured it was a good time to try it again. Well, somehow I ended up with the bad end of the deal! Not sure how the discount was applied, but it wasn’t done correctly. I questioned the cashier, but could tell I wasn’t getting through to her! We will stick with our favorites~Sweet Frog and Menchies!

Cute place near the movie theater. I love the idea of serve yourself and toppings. The yogurt is much softer though but still good. The facility is clean and the employees are nice.

Menchie’s, Whenchies, Cups, Cups and Cakes, Let’s Yo, Tasti D-​Lite, Dee Lite Groove Is In The Heart, Yogurtland, Yogurtbland, TCBY, CSNY, Sweet Frog, 16 Handles, 99 Problems, Yogurberry, Dingleberry, Pinkberry plus a literal freakin’ zillion other copy cats all selling the exact same flavors, texture, taste, experience etc.
Add to that list, Yogurtini. Now coming from PA we had never heard of a Yogurtini since there is one somewhere in NJ but after the nearest one might very well be in Williamsburg. After our less than desirable experience next door at Firehouse we figured let’s try something «different» with this place.
Now the basic idea behind frozen yogurt is not exactly rocket science.
To put it in the simplest of terms, it’s made from combining milk that’s been cultured with live and active cultures with sweetener, a thickening agent, and some sort of flavoring. Then it’s pasteurized, fermented, and frozen.
Some chains no doubt add their own twists with cane sugar versus your garden variety Domino white stuff or tap water versus filtered but at the end of the day everyone more or less is doing the same thing.
Why all of the different stores/​chains around the country? The hell if I know since by-​in-​large I couldn’t tell much of a difference between this place or a chain we have in PA called Yo Fresh.
The one positive is that they do have two different cup sizes where as a lot of the Fro-​Yo chains only have one size which is usually comparable in size to a large helmet.
As for the Yogurt here itself, meh. The peanut butter was runny, the cookies and cream was fairly flavorless and the flavor I tried initially (I forget what is was) I couldn’t really have because when I pulled the lever the machine started to shake, vibrate and nothing came out but a thinish stream of …
The place looks nice enough and the two girls who were working were equally nice but obviously I was very unimpressed with the quality of the product. Maybe during the winter they’re so dead that the product sits too long and becomes not of an ideal consistency/​flavor?
We’ll be back in the Williamsburg area this Summer and while this place is well located if the mood for Fro Yo strikes we’ll try one of the million competitors.

Wow, so I’ve been here a few times and it’s very good. Sweet frog still reigns supreme for me in the fro yo category, but Yogurtini is a close second. I really like the Salted Caramel Corn. The yogurt consistently has a thick and creamy texture. Convenient location in High Street right next to Fireside Subs. High ceilings and exposed piping give the inside a hip, industrial feel. Another nice touch is that instead of the traditional paper cards, Yogurtini saves your info by phone # for its rewards program.