The Top 20 Italian in Fort Collins, CO

Fresh reviews:

Attentive, personable, good-looking staff.I appreciate the light hearted class that Bisetti’s possesses. Fabulous happy hour, too. It’s nice to sit down and be tended to in a dimly lit, warm atmosphere. The jazz, the artwork, the martinis… I enjoyed my early dinner here.Five stars for a pristine, gorgeous…

Melaina N.

Bisetti’s Italian Restaurant

Best pizza in fort collins, hands down! A little pricey but well worth it. Freshest ingredients (there’s not even a freezer in this establishment). Staff is always happy and helpful!

Amber B.

Pulcinella Pizzeria

While in Fort Collins we took the family to Beau Jos for pizza on Saturday night. This place was packed, which I took as a sigh of being in the right place for pizza. We had a vegetarian combo mountain style. The pizza was great! I will be back next time in town.

Geo S.

Beau Jo’s Pizza

Server was nice, atmosphere was nice, but man was the spaghetti gross. I know people get on here and write mean stuff, but seriously, for an Italian restaurant it was just bad. Super overcooked, unseasoned, not actually spaghetti (it was flat not round, seemed closer to linguine). The sauce was how I imagined a…

Jonathan L.

Canino’s Italian Restaurant

When this place first opened it was a five star. Fun atmosphere, great food and reasonable prices and NOT full of college students. The last three times we have gone — atmosphere is eh (not near as busy as it used to be), the food is eh and prices have increased when menu changes to higher prices for less…

Du C. M.

Nick’s Italian

We ordered mussels and two different baked pastas.The mussels were old. We accepted this as our ordering mistake until my boyfriend ate one that had clearly gone bad. He spit it out onto his plate and went to the bathroom to rinse out his mouth. We had eaten most of the mussels and he said he was fine, so we…

T K.

Paninos Restaurant

After hearing that Olive Garden was voted best restaurant in West Arkansas in 2014, I was interested in checking out this fine authentic Italian restaurant. I am originally from West Arkansas, and was driven away in 1998 due to the crisis of the West Arkansas Cheese Ankle Strangler. With that being said, I…