The 10 Best Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Key West, FL, United States

Open map

Fresh reviews:

Very good ice cream. Not a fan of the mint chip though, it’s not minty enough! The cookie selection is large.

Rick A.

Mattheessen’s

Service was great, went at night. Got a Raspberry Sorbetto and ended up being disappointed with it. Should have tried it before buying. But everything looked really good and the smell knocks you off your feet when you walk in (good way).

Amanda W.

Good ice cream. Flavors are okay. The cupcakes in the display case however looked wonderful! You get a good amount of ice cream for the price you pay. I would go back and try the cupcakes.

Stephanie M.

9 places in Key West, ordered by rating:

Mattheessen’s

4.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 305-923-5418
Address:	419 Duval St

Desserts / Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Kilwins

4.7

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 305-320-0986
Address:	505 Duval St

Desserts / Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt / Chocolatiers & Shops

2 Scoops

4.5

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 305-735-4433
Address:	2814 N Roosevelt Blvd

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt / Desserts / Coffee & Tea

Kohr Bros Frozen Custard

4.3

20 reviews

Telephone:	Not provided
Address:	335 Duval St Ste C

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt /

Flamingo Crossing

4.0

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 305-296-6124
Address:	1107 Duval St

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt /

Key Lime Republic

4.0

33 reviews

Telephone:	+1 305-296-9515
Address:	412 Greene St

Desserts / Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt / Bakeries

Key West Polar Bear Homemade Ice Cream

2.9

16 reviews

Telephone:	+1 305-293-9966
Address:	247 Front St

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt /

Key West Ice Cream Factory & Cafe’

2.8

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 305-295-3011
Address:	201 William St Ste 101

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt / Cafes / Coffee & Tea