The 20 Best Sandwiches in Columbus, IN

Fresh reviews:

The service is friendly, my wife and I really enjoyed it, cozy atmosphere. Possibly the best Reuben sandwich I’ve ever eaten. They also serve good deviled eggs. Excellent value

Bradford W.

Big Cheese

Great food, fast service, friendly staff, very clean. Always make it a point to stop here when traveling through.

Sean H.

Jimmy John’s

I love this place. The sandwiches are great and filling. The pasta is baked and great. I have never had a bad heexperiencere.

Matthew B.

Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders

Penn station is a great place to eat. And the food is awesome! I usually get the Philadelphia (Philly) sub. And I’ve never had a problem with it. I get everything but the banana peppers on it. But its out of this world! The staff is always friendly. And the food is served fresh and hot. They’ve also got fresh…

Jesse W.

Penn Station

Panera is a dependable, possibly healthy quick food alternative. Although it doesn’t have anything that I truly crave, it’s always a solid, repeatable performer.The new ANCIENT GRAIN, ARUGULA AND CHICKEN SALAD is a wonderful salad if you enjoy sweet dressings. It has a slaw mixed in with white balsamic…

Dina D.

Panera Bread

Pizza was good, service so-so I am only around this area once or twice a year. Waited to long for refills 5min son had to wait for 10 min. On milk that the server forgot about. When appitizer came out server just set on the side closet to her for and didn’t say or ask if anything was needed. 6 people split at…

Derrick N.

Chicago’s Pizza

Ok we know Subway is a chain so let’s assume the food is generally about the same at most Subways. The reason this received such a low score — four times now I have tried this location. Slowest service imaginable. Kids (and a manager!) who ask multiple times what you had because they aren’t paying attention. I…

Abby D.

Subway

22 places in Columbus, ordered by rating:

Domino’s Pizza

5.0

3 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-348-6300
Address:	1770 25th St

Big Cheese

4.6

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-376-3567
Address:	2403 Cottage Ave

Sandwiches /

Jimmy John’s

4.1

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-378-0000
Address:	1675 N National Rd

Sandwiches /

Jimmy John’s

4.0

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-378-5466
Address:	2115 W Jonathan Moore Pike

Sandwiches /

Subway

4.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 812-378-2929
Address:	2345 Beam Rd

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders

3.6

12 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-375-1000
Address:	1301 N National Rd

Pizza / Sandwiches

Penn Station

3.7

6 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-372-7600
Address:	1310 N National Rd

Sandwiches /

Panera Bread

3.6

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-375-9421
Address:	2215 National Rd

Sandwiches / American (New)

Chicago’s Pizza

3.7

10 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-657-7003
Address:	3780 W Jonathan Moore Pike

Pizza / Sandwiches

Arni’s

3.1

10 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-375-2700
Address:	2765 Brentwood Dr

Pizza / Salad / Sandwiches

Subway

3.2

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 812-378-0621
Address:	2443 W Jonathan Moore Pike

Fast Food / Sandwiches

Subway

2.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 812-375-0140
Address:	1010 25th St

Fast Food / Sandwiches

Subway

2.0

1 review

Telephone:	Not provided
Address:	2525 State St

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 812-314-2259
Address:	2601 State St

Fast Food / Sandwiches

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 812-376-3581
Address:	1130 25th St

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Marcos Pizza

···

Telephone:	+1 812-375-1500
Address:	2019 25th St

Pizza / Sandwiches / Chicken Wings

Subway

···

Telephone:	Not provided
Address:	3107-3199 E 25th St

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 812-378-2602
Address:	735 Whitfield Dr

Sandwiches / Fast Food

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 812-372-1326
Address:	2025 Merchant Mile

Fast Food / Sandwiches

Subway

···

Telephone:	+1 203-877-4281
Address:	4280 W Jonathan Moore Pike

Sandwiches / Fast Food

The 20 Best Sandwiches

Columbus, IN, United States

Fresh reviews:

22 places in Columbus, ordered by rating: