The 10 Best Italian in Amherst, MA

Fresh reviews:

Nothing to complain about. The pizzas are always cooked properly with fresh ingredients. Not greasy like almost every other place around. Can be a little pricey, but the quality of the pizza easily makes up for that.

D W.

Sibies Pizza

Plentiful, tasty and inexpensive. The starter soup at lunch was the perfect way to kick off the meal.

Scott F.

Crazy Noodles

I feel their Unilocal rating was false. There is no way this place is 4.5 stars. Their chicken tasted like it came out of a can. None of the dishes blew me away. And it was over priced.

Nick D.

Osteria Vespa

Was here on Valentine’s 2016, to visit Amherst college the next day. I’m from NYC originally, so I know restaurants.Service was slow. Place was a lot bigger than it seems, because it has a whole back room. The food, however, was solidly mediocre.My partner and I both started with the Lobster Chowder, because it…