Sibies Pizza

Amherst, United States

4.2

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 413-256-6100
Website:
www.sibiespizza.com
Address:
481 West St, Amherst, MA, 01002
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
270 ftDairy Mart (Out)
320 ftPomeroy Lane (E)
400 ftDairy Mart (In)
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Dinner
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Divey
Noise Level
Quiet
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Amherst) 9:38 AM Thursday, May 22, 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Sunday 1:00 pm – 8:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Buying fresh, locally grown, dairy and produce, and using unbleached and unbromated flour, we at SIBIES strive to serve the highest quality food available.

A small, local, family business!

History

Established in 2001.

George Duranti took over CANTONES pizza in 2001 and transformed it into SIBIES, an award winning pizza and sub shop.

Meet the Business Owner

George D.

Business Owner

George took over CANTONES pizza in 2001. With a makeover of the menu and a few healthier additions, CANTONES was quickly transformed into SIBIES pizza.

Sibies Pizza also recommends

Henion Bakery

21

reviews

Bakeries

George D. says,

«Everything.»

Related places

You might also consider:
1.9
mi
Domino’s Pizza
459 Russell St
2.1
mi
Big Y World Class Market
175 University Dr
2.3
mi
Athena’s Pizza
65 University Dr Ste 1
2.5
mi
Alpha Pizza Pi
356 College St
2.5
mi
Pizzarama
356 College St
2.5
mi
Bruno’s
363 Main St

Vicinity

Browse nearby places:
40
ft
Mission Cantina
485 W St
270
ft
Subway
468 West St
270
ft
Valley Transporter
479 West St Ste 10
270
ft
Jayadeva Yoga School
479 W St Ste 80
270
ft
Dancer Computers
479 W St Ste 6B
320
ft
Kumon Math and Reading Center of Amherst
7 Pomeroy Lane Suite #5

20 reviews of Sibies Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Amherst, MA
Awesome pizza and subs. Delivery arrived in a timely matter. Some toppings are a little pricey, but overall great quality food!
Place rating: 5
San Francisco, CA
This place has excellent service and excellent food. I have been going here for years and I have never been disappointed. give it a try!
Place rating: 5
South Hadley, MA
Nothing to complain about. The pizzas are always cooked properly with fresh ingredients. Not greasy like almost every other place around. Can be a little pricey, but the quality of the pizza easily makes up for that.
Place rating: 5
Hadley, MA
This is my favorite pizza place. The owner and his family are present all the time, which gives you that special customer service and personal attention. This place has great VEGAN OPTIONS!!!
Try the vegan pizza !! As for the standard pizza shop fare, the pizza’s come out with fresh ingredients. The subs are fab. as well. I believe the Mediterranean sub, either veggie or with the lamb is popular and many of my friends enjoy on a regular basis. Another big it is the buffalo chicken wings! YEP BEST IN AMHERST. I challenge you to try them.
Place rating: 5
Hadley, MA
BEST pizza in Amherst, no question! This is a family business with amazing and fresh options. The owner, George and his two children who work with him will always go out of their way to make sure you have the best food experience! Try the spinach crust. Awesome!
Place rating: 5
Hampshire, MA
Best Pizza in Amherst!
I have lived here for 28 years. This is the most consistent restaurant with the best crust, the best sauce and the best toppings EVER… There is nothing else to say… I get my pizza fix every Thursday…
Place rating: 5
South Deerfield, MA
Great service. Good pizza. George went out of his way to make sure we had pizza delivered for our Sunday party. Thanks George!
Place rating: 4
INDIAN ORCH, MA
I liked the chicken parm grinder I got here. The free bag of chips and cole slaw was a nice perk. I might come here again. Note there’s no indoor seating, just two picnic tables outside.
Place rating: 2
Amherst, MA
Snagged a slice from my roommate. Looked alright, but the oil was off like it was cheap as hell and old. Seems to be a thing with pizzerias, but can’t give many stars regardless.
Place rating: 5
South Amherst, MA
Wow! Healthy pizza!
I’m so excited to live near Sibies Pizza! Where else will you find a whole-​wheat pizza crust option? Not to mention a vegan cheese option, and even an almost-​gluten-​free pizza crust option! (As wheat free as a pizza can be when there is flour dust everywhere.)
They also feature three different vegetarian specials, that all sounds so good it is hard to choose. So far my family has been enjoying the Mediterranean Veggie so much that we have yet to try one of the others. Even my kids like it!
Not a sitdown place, this is the place to pick up a pizza, or have it delivered. There are no seats, unless you count a picnic table outside. That said, if you want a nice place to sit down with your pizza, I believe the bar across the street, the well regarded Moan and Dove, allows you to bring food in. Maybe call and double check, but that’s what someone told me!
Place rating: 5
Orange, CA
Dank first experience. Great fries that are to die for! Huge portions too. Perfect for those lunch and a snack later kind of days.
Place rating: 4
Hadley, MA
The party pizzas taste better than the regular ones. As to why, I don’t know, but it’s all partay from here on out for me :)
Place rating: 4
Manhattan, NY
Generally, I prefer a thin crust pizza. While Sibies is on the thicker side, I still enjoy it. I’m not really into some of their crazier pizzas (taco, por ejemplo), but I LOVE their thin crust tomato basil! ingredients taste fresh. The subs are good-​the veggie burger blast is amazing. Wish the bread was a little harder, but maybe that’s just me. Basically, Sibies is great for what it is. Very affordable, and they deliver pints of Ben & Jerrys!
Place rating: 3
Amherst, MA
Oh Sibies. Where to begin? Pizza here can be hit or miss. Sometimes it’s great, other times it’s «meh.» I asked for pineapple on my pizza and I barely got any, and what was there was weirdly distributed. Most the pizza slices only had a couple little triangles per cut, while 2 slices seemed to have most the meager pineapple I was allotted. While I enjoyed those 2 slices, I would have liked the others more had there been more pineapple (or a better distribution of it.) The sauce to cheese ratio is inconsistent, sometimes it’s good, sometimes I question whether they’ve forgotten to put sauce on the pizza and are hoping no one notices.
Pro: Consistently fast delivery.
Place rating: 5
South Hadley, MA
Best pizza in the area, in my opinion. Yes, there are other places that are good, but Sibie’s is the only place I crave. Love their delicious, chewy whole wheat crust. White sauce is a little greasy and garlicky for my taste, but red sauce is nice and toppings are good. Got an OK sub here once, but definitely plan to stick with whole wheat pizza from now on. Very run down, but it’s takeout or delivery only, so it doesn’t much matter. They always have coupons on their website, so make sure to look for those.
Place rating: 1
Herndon, VA
I wish I could give this place zero stars. I ordered take out for myself and a few people. My order was a cheeseburger sub, PLAIN, no lettuce or tomato, and especially no pickles which I do not like at all. When I called back to try and get the order correct, I was put on hold and then when I told the OWNER that my order was wrong he made it seem like it was a huge issue to recook another one. I asked if there was a problem and he said he didn’t understand why I couldn’t pick off all the ingredients I didn’t want in the first place. He then said he would make another one and at that point I was insulted and wanted nothing to do having a disgruntled employee remaking a sub for me. I asked for a refund and was told no. I’m brand new to Amherst and have been treated horribly at restaurants and bars but this is by far the worst of it all.
IF your customer is a hassle for trying to get an order they are paying for correct you are in the wrong business.
Place rating: 3
Amherst, MA
Decent pizza, good for a college area. Perfect for a quick lunch but I’ve found that the quality of food isn’t always consistent.
Place rating: 4
Niskayuna, NY
Pretty much take-​out only, with one futon and one armchair to wait in, but every time we’ve ever tried them they’ve delivered decent neapolitan-​style pizza very quickly. As a neighborhood sort-​of-​college-​town pizzeria, you could do worse, and indeed in previous years several franchises at the corners here in South Amherst have done worse. With the Moan & Dove catty-​corner (you can take your pizza in there and eat it with expensive beer and very low lighting) it makes for a fine combination.
Place rating: 3
Amherst, MA
Inconsistent is the best term I can think of. The first time we ordered a pizza here it was pretty decent. The chicken fingers we got for my son were really tasty as well. The second time the pizza was over sauced and with too much cheese, so instead of hanging together it just sort of fell apart as you tried to it eat. The excess sauce ruined any chance of a slightly crispy crust that I enjoy.
Adding a star because upon reading my review the owner reached out to apologize for the inconsistency and make it right. Service like that counts!
Place rating: 5
Brooklyn, NY
Traditional puffy-​style pizza. With REAL fresh veggies (not canned mushrooms). My 5 stars may be biased because I was really hungry and just had an awesome slice of mushroom & green pepper pizza. Mmmmmmm! Note — they only do slices for lunch.