The 10 Best Bakeries in Montclair, NJ

Fresh reviews:

This small coffee café is amazing! Their menemeh and simit bread always tasting fresh and delicious. Never disappoints.

Kathy C.

My go-to spot for donuts. Prices are a bit expensive between 2 and $ 4 per donut but you’re getting a superior quality product as compared to the crap they sell at fast food donut shops. Plan to arrive early as sometimes they sell out. Street parking only. They also sell tasty breakfast sandwiches. I highly…

J P.

Montclair Bread Company

For Applegate itself, 2.5 stars. For the Graham Central Station flavor, I give 5+ stars. If I’m coming here, that’s for sure what I’m ordering. I strayed from the path once to be ~adventurous~ and was filled with instant regret. Graham Central is packed with crunchy bits of graham cracker coated in chocolate…

Samantha L.

Applegate Farm Ice Cream

Maybe the bread is better? The cupcakes we bought were old tasting/not fresh, dense and dry, and covered with inedible piles of icing and stale sprinkles that went in the garbage. Disappointing, since the restaurant is so yummy.

Suzanne D.

Plum Bakery

No consistency in prices. The difference between a regular loaf of bread and semolina bread is pennies. Today I ordered a sandwich on semolina and was charged 6 dollars more then the regular sandwich for the same size. I drive 30 minutes to get there but the commute and being ripped off has now turned me off…