The 10 Best Bakeries in Nutley, NJ

Fresh reviews:

Ordered a cake for a repass, the cake was fresh and appropriately decorated for such an event. The bakers were easy to work with, and the cake was delicious. Everyone at the repass commented on how tasty the cake was. Will be back for more cake orders soon.

Jessica F.

DaVinci Bakery

Ordered a birthday cake and it was absolutely delicious. Excellent customer service and extremely friendly staff.

Rey S.

Aromi Di Napoli

This review is for a chocolate cake that Boyfriend ordered for my birthday. It was fabulous, with fresh fruit in it and a really nice buttercream frosting. Everybody was really pleasantly surprised by how good the cake was, since we generally do ice cream cakes for birthdays, and was asking where it came…

Elizabeth M.

Plaza Pastry Shop

I moved to Nutley from Las Vegas 3 months ago.I love all the little cafes and mom and pop restaurants.Today me and my son came in and had a «moms favorite» and I ordered «the Nutley»A little disappointed there was a more empowered chocolate taste than the Nutella.I didn’t taste it at all actually.I wouldn’t…