The 10 Best Pizza in Garden City, NY

Fresh reviews:

We visited on a Sunday in the early evening. It was pretty empty so we were told to sit wherever we wanted.The menu is limited to pizza, salad and just a few other appetizers. We ordered the portabella napolen as an appetizer ($ 10). The serving was small not really enough to share and mostly consisted of…

Zaneta O.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

Vey un-welcoming place, I went in the other day for some lunch. The women said to me «what do you want» I was shock to hear this from someone working in a pizza place.The food is ok, not the best.They are also very expensive for a pizza place.

Mike E.

Skinny Pizza

So I place an order for a pie with 3 toppings on it, pretty simple, I’m Catholic and it’s Good Friday so I’m not allowed to have meat. They deliver the wrong pie so I simply called them to please bring the right pie. They tell me to come pick up the new pie and bring the other one back. I request for someone to…

Joseph F.

Umberto’s of Garden City

Yeah The New Upgrades Are Very Nice And All… But The Food Sucks Bad Tried A Few Places Here And There Way Over Priced And Just Plain Suck ! I Once Payed $ 13 Bucks For A Baked Potato That Was Cold And Taste Like Water Which Is Hard To Do Since They Say Baked ?All The Employees Are Confused And Stare At You With…

Iknow F.

Dining District

First of all the owner of this restaurant was rude to me right off the bat. They overcharged me for old tasteless pizza.Then as I was trying to eat in their sparsely air conditioned space, the owner and an employee began yelling at each other incessantly. It was unprofessional and the vibe was simply…

Elliot Y.

Gallery Pizzeria & Restaurant

11 places in Garden City, ordered by rating:

Centurion Pizza Plaza

5.0

1 review

Telephone:	+1 516-486-9081
Address:	279 Nassau Blvd S

Pizza /

Umberto’s of Garden City

4.1

16 reviews

Telephone:	+1 516-481-1279
Address:	361 Nassau Blvd S

Pizza / Italian

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

4.0

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 516-294-6565
Address:	980 Franklin Ave

Pizza /

Dining District

3.8

20 reviews

Telephone:	Not provided
Address:	Roosevelt Field 630 Old Country Rd

Vegetarian / Pizza

Skinny Pizza

3.3

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 516-739-8899
Address:	Roosevelt Field Mall 630 Old Country Rd

Pizza /

Garden City Pizza

3.7

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 516-294-2929
Address:	670 Franklin Ave

Pizza / Italian

Gallery Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.4

16 reviews

Telephone:	+1 516-354-6102
Address:	52 New Hyde Park Rd

Pizza / Italian

Rustica Brick Oven Cafe

3.5

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 516-292-2197
Address:	1 Nassau Blvd

Pizza / Italian

Pizza Supreme

3.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 516-228-4300
Address:	678 Stewart Ave

Pizza /

Patsy’s Pizza

2.5

6 reviews

Telephone:	Not provided
Address:	Roosevelt Field 630 Old Country Rd

Pizza /

Umbertos

···

Telephone:	+1 516-481-1279
Address:	361 Nassau Blvd

Pizza /

Pizza in nearby cities:

Jackson Heights

Atlantic Beach

West Bronx

The 10 Best Pizza

Garden City, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

11 places in Garden City, ordered by rating:

Pizza in nearby cities: