The 20 Best Sandwiches in Ithaca, NY

Fresh reviews:

I almost hate cluing everyone in on what a great little place this is! You will not find a better fish sandwich/dinner anywhere (I’m looking at you, Doug’s Fish Fry) and for the most reasonable prices. Owners are always there, as friendly as can be, and with recent renovations there are a few tables you can…

Karen C.

Red & White Cafe

Thai chicken wrap is on point, and the Americanos here are the best BRBs can buy on campus.

Anthony P.

Café Jennie

Today I had a great experience that just made my bad day great again. I go through the drive threw and order my bagel and tea and realized I left my wallet at home I go to tell them to void my order bc I can’t pay and they hand it to me and say «everyone has those days». I go there every day before work and…

Erika G.

Panera Bread

33⁄100)This place is basically what many of the other reviewers said. I’m not from Ithaca, but I absolutely see the hometown appeal and late night popularity. I went to college too and there was definitely a place like this I loved. I imagine every college area has at least one.The sandwiches were gigantic…

Cara S.

Shortstop Deli

Cozy, upscale brunch spot with very interesting menu options featuring diverse ingredients. Very small and popular, so expect a bit of a wait but the beautiful outdoor garden or the roomy upstairs lounge are great places to pass the time. 5 stars for atmosphere and service, 4 stars for food and beverage…

Jillian C.

Carriage House Cafe

Every time I find myself needing to be on South Hill, I always tryto plan it around lunchtime so I have an excuse to have lunch at Rogans. Their sandwiches/subs are great. For those of you who are longtime Ithaca residents the sandwiches/subs are the menu from the old King Sub in the west end. Big fan of the…

Adam Z.

Rogan’s Corner

I ordered at 6:17pm on a Sat night. I called the store to say Grubhub had the wrong address on the order. The person on the phone assured me he would pass the message along to the driver. An hour and 20min later I get a call from the driver from the wrong address. I explained to the driver he was supposed to be…