The Top 10 Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in Ithaca, NY

Fresh reviews:

Delicious! I had the «Blueberry Goat Cheesecake Muffin», and wowzas was it good. Super creamy with chunks of muffin. Not too sweet either.Plenty of seating available. You can ask them for samples if you are having trouble deciding (I did this for the cheesecake and the raspberry chocolate truffle and the former…

Linda L.

Purity Ice Cream

THE BEST FROYO I HAVE EVER HAD!!! I went all the time when I lived in Ithaca and now I try to go every time I am in town to visit! A great range of flavors that rotate often, plus it is made of Greek yogurt so it is filling but not heavy. The taste is amazing, unlike the other frozen yogurts that taste like…

Elysha R.

Smart Yogurt

I’ve been here a couple of times as a student, and I came back as an alumnus — definitely one of the highlights in terms of food in Ithaca. They have really interesting flavors (pink peppercorn, nilla ice — Nilla wafers in vanilla ice cream), and even their standard staples are pretty good.The only drawback is…

Austin K.

Sweet Melissa’s Ice Cream Shop

The upsides:Fresh fruit offerings are always abundant and very fresh.They have a «discount» card/app.Free sample cups.Real whipped cream.The downsides:The trashcan is always overflowing.There is no recycle bin offered for the spoons, so there is a boatload of waste.The cups offered for water are plastic = MORE…