The Top 10 Pizza in Montgomery, NY

Fresh reviews:

I didn’t order anything special yet, just a «personal» calzone (baked or fried, your choice)…and I was impressed by the portion I received that was too big for a plate for $ 6.95. I didn’t see the menu until after I picked up my order but it’s pretty extensive and includes a catering menu. My food was good and…

Shane V.

Carmela’s Pizza Restaurant

Went out on Friday night with family of four. Have not been here in 10 years for no reason but decided to choose here for a change. I ordered veal parm, wife with chic Marsala, one with penne vodka and the other with shrimp fettuccine Alfredo. We started with the fried calamari which was nice and tender with an…

Shady C.

Carmela’s Pizza Restaurant

The only reason why this is 4 stars and not 5 is because my fussy friend doesn’t like orange cheese on her salad. We were weary travelers on I84 and this was most likely spot for lunch. My other two friends and I chose $ 8.95 lunch specials that were pasta, small side salad and beverage. The rolls are…

Donna F.

Cascarino’s

really? 4⁄5 stars — if frozen meatballs, canned sauce and overcooked chicken rate high at an Italian joint this place should have 11 out of 10 stars — Pizza is do-able though.