The Top 20 Pizza in New Windsor, NY

Fresh reviews:

Excellent Italian fare in this unassuming little strip mall pizza place. Their pizza was excellent and we had a shrimp parmigiana hero, which was delicious! Their house brand sodas were a nice original touch, which my family enjoyed. The staff was friendly, the food was served quickly and hot — and all in all…

Penny M.

Mama Theresa’s Pizza

Great people and Great Pizza. Mike could not have been Nicer. Quick service and great variety of slices and Pies. You have gotta try the Vegetable pie!

Cook N' Critic Mmm…

Pizza Mia

Good food but employees and owners are very rude. They need to work on their customer service because we have many other Italian restaurant in New Windsor that provide great food with exceptional customer service and would love our business. Therefore, revise your hospitality atmosphere or loose business.

Lumie C.

Ivana’s Cucini

First time eating here. We had passed it and figured, can’t go wrong with Italian food. Actually, you can. We won’t be going back.

Andrea B.

Capri Restaurant & Pizzeria

23 places in New Windsor, ordered by rating:

Preet Gourmet Pizza & Deli

5.0

3 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-567-3409
Address:	1035 Little Britain Rd

Pizza / Delis

Cousins Pizzeria

4.8

4 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-863-0800
Address:	2915 Rte 9W

Pizza /

Pizza Mia

4.6

20 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-563-9100
Address:	176 Windsor Hwy Ste 600

Pizza /

Clearwater’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.4

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-565-3650
Address:	318 Blooming Grove Tpke

Pizza /

Cinema Pizza

4.5

4 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-563-0280
Address:	215 Quassaick Ave

Pizza /

Mama Theresa’s Pizza

4.4

15 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-561-6262
Address:	374 Windsor Hwy

Pizza /

Pizza Heaven

4.1

10 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-569-8888
Address:	291 Old Forge Hill Rd

Pizza /

Frank’s Pizzeria

4.0

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-565-4600
Address:	179 Temple Hill Rd

Pizza /

Ivana’s Cucini

4.1

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-561-8700
Address:	145 Windsor Hwy

Pizza / Italian

Marcelino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.0

8 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-569-9100
Address:	1020 State Rt 94

Pizza /

Primos Pizza

3.8

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-569-4463
Address:	573 Union Ave

Pizza /

Capri Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.6

19 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-562-2170
Address:	359 Windsor Hwy

Pizza / Salad / Seafood

Sal’s

3.4

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-561-8484
Address:	434 Blooming Grove Tpke

Pizza /

A B C Pizza & Restaurant

2.9

7 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-562-2060
Address:	198 Quassaick Ave

Pizza / Italian

Two Brothers

3.2

11 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-567-0700
Address:	904 Little Britain Rd

American (Traditional) / Delis / Pizza

Plum Tomato Pizza And Heros

3.0

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-569-1010
Address:	2915 US Route 9W

Pizza /

Napoli Pizzeria

2.8

5 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-565-4870
Address:	359 Windsor Hwy

Pizza /

Domino’s Pizza

2.7

9 reviews

Telephone:	+1 845-562-0300
Address:	401 Windsor Hwy

Pizza / Chicken Wings / Sandwiches

Angora Pizza & kabob

···

Telephone:	+1 845-401-7735
Address:	815 Blooming Grove Tpk

Pizza /

Ventura Pizzeria

···

Telephone:	+1 845-562-2784
Address:	266 Quassaick Ave

Pizza / Italian

Newburgh

Walden

Campbell Hall

The Top 20 Pizza

New Windsor, NY, United States

Fresh reviews:

23 places in New Windsor, ordered by rating:

Pizza in nearby cities: