Clearwater’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

The best pizza we have found in New Windsor area. We really don’t go anywhere else. Our fav… the garbage pie!

Clearwater, Clearwater how I love thee! This pizza shop is like the girl (guy) you meet that you’re not head over heals for but eventually realize she’s (he’s) an absolute dream to be with.
I have never updated a review for a place 3 times but I have to say I’ve fallen in love with this little gem. Store has been downsized to take-​out only so their definitely is no dining in option. Owner takes notice to his regulars and genuinely appreciates the business. Pizza for the past 3 years has been very consistent and the heroes the owner makes are pretty amazing. I don’t live close to this place but make the 10+ mile drive to get pizza here. Oh yea did I mention prices are fair & reasonable despite rising costs of living. I’ve recommended this place countless times even to my neighbors in the distance.
I’ve definitely fallen in love with this place. «Will you marry me Clearwater Pizza?»

My absolute favorite take out /​delivery pizza place in this area. The pizza sauce and pasta sauce, the dough is all made from scratch. It’s so tasty.
The steak and cheeses are also excellent, I am partial to the chicken Marsala dinner with a side of broccoli.
But ANYTHING with their homemade pasta sauce is the best, Meatball Parms, baked ziti, mmmmm. I am hungry just thinking about it.
Give it a shot you will be back for more.

Husband and I decided to try this place out last night after receiving a discounted coupon in the mail. Place was easy to find on route 94 (right accross from Cumberland Farms). We came in through side door, on the right side there was seating but the lights were off, which makes me think that this place is mostly for pick up?. The restaurant could use fresh coat paint and some upgrades, the gentle man there was abrupt, but as for the plain pizza it was delicious, it was still hot when we got it home and crust was great, sauce and cheese were perfect.

Tried it yesterday. Good pizza, the chicken parmesan hero was good and the Fettuccine Alfredo was really good. Delivery was fast.