The 10 Best Italian in Plainview, NY

Fresh reviews:

La Bottega is under new ownership and, man, they are killing it! They have a special menu every week and awesome cocktails. Their Brazilian Mango Caipirinha and the Polenta Fritte off their special menu is the perfect combo to kick off your weekend! Come check them out! Also, their homemade pasta and panini are…

Angelica S.

La Bottega

Well… had the pie been hot or even warm it would have been really really good. However it was not either. Also there were no napkins, no red pepper flakes, no parmesan cheese on the side as specifically requested. Would I order it again? Yes possibly if I was sitting in the restaurant. This was for delivery it…

Angel O.

La Piazza

I’ve been going to Mr. Joe’s since it opened, but I doubt I will be going back. The service and quality of food has decreased steadily over the past year or so and my recent trips there have been very disappointing.I used to be a big fan of their buffalo chicken pie, but the slices got much smaller, with much…

Bryan B.

Mr Joe’s Pizzeria & Ristorante

Horrible horrible and horrible !!! At 840 on Saturday, we called to see how long the wait was. We were told no wait. We arrived at 850 and were told two minutes by the same gentleman we spoke to on the phone. This manager or owner or whoever he was disappeared and re appeared at 920 to tell us another two…