The 10 Best Pizza in Suffern, NY

Fresh reviews:

Best Italian Food and meat rice in beans! Fast friendly service. A true family business!

Jeffrey G.

At a party today that was catered by this restaurant and everything was absolutely delicious! And a great deal according to the host

Megan V.

Il Villaggio Pizzeria Restaurant

I ordered a wrap with fries for lunch and it cost me $ 13. I could have a better sandwich and a beer for less money right down the road. Pretty sure it was the owner who charged me and he must have added a goodbye fee because there are much better options in Suffern/Mahwah.

Drew D.

Nicky’s Pizza & Heroes Shop

Negligent cooks and owner!!! Ordered linguini and clams to-go and ended with a broken tooth. They cook food with seafood shells INSIDE the sauce. I tried calling the owner, MARK several times and only answered when I threatened with an attorney, and with an aggressive tone says he won’t do anything. I’m a…