Pizza in Wallkill, NY

Fresh reviews:

Great food and friendly staff. The buffalo chicken pizza is out of this world. Highly recommended and this is coming from someone who grew up on Long Island/NYC. Easily the best pizza in the area.

Andrew J.

San Marino’s Restaurant and Pizzeria

We ordered the fried chicken and it was the worst we ever had first off it was over cooked and the batter was sweet. Stick with the pizza it’s your best bet.

Don P.

Tosco’s Pizzeria

Closed for good !!!&$ 4(((;;(:;)&&9!?;,???))???;;?!‘mmhnmjgcbfbnnvfghjjhgbvfdcvbjitrfbjkjdfbffggIs now a bagel shop

D G.

Fat Mikes Pizza & Deli

I’m really only giving this place one star because pizza can never be bad enough to earn zero. I called for pizza and wings to pickup and was told they were out of wings. So I asked for chicken fingers which they were also apparently out of. I should have just assumed they were out of pizza too and left it at…