The Top 10 Pizza in New Castle, PA

Fresh reviews:

I turned 16 in 1986 and got my driver’s license and was eager to check out the local food joints. Mangino’s was my «go to» place for dinner on Friday nights. I tried to eat healthy food all week that my Mommy cooked for me, but on Fridays I would celebrate a tough week at school by stopping by Mangino’s and…

Tim M.

Mangino’s Pizzeria

Farone’s has great food for a great price. When you eat in, you get salad, bread, and dessert with your meal for a small price. When you order delivery, it’s always delivered quickly. I also highly recommend them for catering. Twice, I have had their catered food, and not only was the food excellent, but they…

Becky Y.

Farone Brothers

Pizza was very chuck e cheese like. Staff was very friendly though and salad was good. Delivery was quicker then promised.

Josh E.

Pizzas By Marchelloni

It’s just not that good. Bathrooms are dirty too. Staff didn’t seem to know what was going on either and the food was meh.

Allison R.

2 Tomato

Taste like the cheese is fake. Used to be great pizza now Croton taste like Highland ave Pizza Joes. Both fake

JD D.

Pizza Joe’s

We all know what dominos food is like. It’s not worth mentioning here. The thing that distinguishes one dominos from another is their service. I ordered a medium pie on a Wednesday afternoon at noon and didn’t get it until it 1:45. It was stone cold and the delivery person barely offered me an apology…