The 10 Best Italian in New Castle, PA

Fresh reviews:

Excellent service! Food is always right on. Come back time and time again! Would recommend to anyone in new castle.

Kelly K.

We have ordered from Mr Pizza several times since our first experience here, two or three times being delivery. Our most recent call to Mr Pizza, they advised my husband that they don’t deliver north of McDonalds in Neshannock. Unfortunately my husband did not challenge this statement considering they have…

Rachel C.

Mr Pizza

Unfortunately Tanner’s was not a location we will be returning to. Upon arriving the wasn’t anyone at the front to take our names, inquiry about the wait or otherwise. There was just a line of people waiting so we waited as well. After 10 mins the first party was sat and so on until it was our turn, which was…

Rachel C.

Chuck Tanners Restaurant

It’s just not that good. Bathrooms are dirty too. Staff didn’t seem to know what was going on either and the food was meh.

Allison R.

2 Tomato

I’ve never eaten here. This one star rating is simply because while attending an event here there was not one single server who would wait on my table. I asked at least 3 different servers if they would help me and they all said it either wasn’t their table or I could go to the bar and get it myself. Just plain…