Pagley’s Pasta & More

Excellent service! Food is always right on. Come back time and time again! Would recommend to anyone in new castle.

Normally love this place. But tonight they are busy, yet we sat at our table (only 2 of us) for 15 minutes before a waiter came to take our order. Not sure if understaffed or just missed us. Even owner walked by and said to staff «this table needs waited on». The good is excellent here. The greens are amazing. I don’t come to New Castle often, but this is always a must.

Awesome Italian food, that is cheap and hearty. Is completely casual and is definitely a must have while in New Castle. The Smelts are one of a kind and a great appetizer. And ask for the «CAV/​RAV» half cavetellis half ravioli

I love their HOMEMADE CAVATELLI and meatballs. I order it with the SPICY HOUSE sauce … Delicious!!! Just go!!!

The absolutely best ravioli you have ever eaten is at Pagley’s. And don’t forget the meatballs! Delicious. But don’t expect great ambiance. The food makes up for any lack of ambiance. Service is prompt and friendly. Enjoy!

The trick to Pagley’s is to order your takeout meal as you enjoy a glass of red at the bar. They can’t ignore you too much if you stroll on in and sit down at the bar. Wait for your food there! The food is The Best in New Castle but as others indicate the service, vibe, décor, staff are just plain «New Castle.»

A prime cut steak for 15 bux? Delicious. The best in new castle. Their Italian dishes are always amazing too. Love this place!!!

The service was good and the food was great. We had everything from pizza and wings to sausage and steak Alfredo. Everyone was happy. And we had 9 people.

They had great food and love their chicken but it’s only for parties so poo
Atmosphere is wonderful
And service was great

Probably wouldn’t go back. The floors were dirty with food and linen when we walked in. Service was slow and the food was OK. Had gnocchi and the sauce tasted a little sour. Could have been an off night?

Acceptable food, cafeteria-​like atmosphere.

Service was bad. Had to wait about 20 min. to even get our drinks. And a long time to get our food. Waitress never even came back to ask if we needed anything else. Don’t go here if your rushed for time or on a lunch hour. Food was good, just not hot enough.

I love this place. Atmosphere is okay but the food is tremendous and extremely value priced. I enjoyed the veal parmesan and penne and their sweet house sauce is excellent.

Good food. Had the cavatelli. Only complaint was the slow service for takeout. When a guy comes in after you, gets a table, gets his food, then leaves all before your order is ready… there’s a problem. My rating is for the food alone.

We used to eat here about once a month. Pasta was great and everything else was pretty good. To be completely honest we no longer go here, the hostess and staff are in deferent and not welcoming at all, may not be a big deal for some but for my money I will go else ware.

Anthony’s favorite, bowl of wedding soup and side of spaghetti. Game over. This place is a treasure that I go out of my way to enjoy.

Raviolis the size of my head? Yes, please!
Great food at a reasonable price — awkward atmosphere (very cold) and I hate that the TV is always on; I’d much rather get take-​out from here… yum.

All marinara has meat fat, so, went for Alfredo sauce. Guess everything has broth because my stomach was jacked up. Flavors were good, not great. Gets pretty crowded on a Saturday night. Atmosphere very «budget.»

I’ve eaten here and the food is good but the last two times I’ve gone, after we got seated but before we placed our orders, I decided to leave. There’s a terrible odor in the restaurant that smelled like the toilets overflowed and they tried to cover the smell by pouring bleach on it.
I hope they get this issue resolved because I really liked going there.

I called Pagley’s for takeout on a Thursday evening. I was told it would be 25 minutes before it would be ready. I arrived at the appropriate time and entered the front door of the restaurant. This place is the most chaotic restaurant I have ever visited. The wait staff is running around like their hair is on fire. The person that is at the cash register and check in desk is one of their youngest employees. Customers are seated randomly without regard to who arrives first. I stood there waiting for my pickup order for ten minutes before i was acknowledged. I thought I was invisible. Finally the young man asked me how I could be helped and I told him I had a pickup order. Surprisingly, it was ready. The food was good. The Chicken Pastina soup was tasty and the lasagna and meatballs were ok.
Overall the food is pretty good but I would NEVER eat at the restaurant but only do takeout. It is a frighteningly chaotic world inside. Management needs to control the reception area and tables a LOT better.