Hey, I just got some food from here for the second time and it was very delicious. I am german and sometimes I wish to have the food from Germany, not necessarily the German food. Also the Italian food from real Italians that have restaurants in Germany. From anything I ate that was supposed to be Italian here, this was the best! They have a very good variety of pasta dishes which I love and the pasta is very very good. I’m very happy I found this place. I have not tried their pizza yet but I will next time. It looks very delicious too. Just give it a try, I can’t imagine you will be disappointed.
Adam L.
Place rating: 5 Riverview, FL
Just like back in Jersey. This place takes me home. Pizza is awesome. Try the chicken parm.
Jeanne L.
Place rating: 5 Seffner, FL
Best meatball sub I ever had! Stromboli was fantastic! Great food! Prices even better! We will certainly be back!
Krysia K.
Place rating: 2 Brandon, FL
Very average. The food was very mediocre. I was expecting better food.
J R.
Place rating: 5 Valrico, FL
Top notch pizza! The service is good! Don’t be fooled by the owners scowl on his face, he is a nice guy… He just kinda don’t smile… But the food is worth the price every time! And the place is clean!
Kathy P.
Place rating: 4 Valrico, FL
Normally everything is on spot but my husband and I had a couple slices and it wasn’t good. There was hardly any sauce. Hopefully next time it will be better. Rosario was not there(Sunday).
Jaime S.
Place rating: 5 Tampa, FL
Good pizza. They knew we were first timers and made sure we knew all the options we had. Got a broccoli cheese calzone and pizza along w 5 garlic knots and a large pizza.(Garlic knots were ok. I like them more gummy if that makes sense) their marinara is actually pretty good. Pizza was to die for and so was the calzone. Being from philly– this place hit it on the nose. Better than the last 2 pizza places I been to
Dan H.
Place rating: 5 Valrico, FL
Very good. I have eaten there several times, never a bad meal. Good lunch specials. Love it.
Katie M.
Place rating: 4 Valrico, FL
As a New Yorker I can say they have realllllly good pizza but it can sometimes be crazy greasy like to the point that everything is sliding off. They are also really hard to find unless you know they are there, but its definitely worth a stop for a slice to make your own opinion!
Peter B.
Place rating: 1 Tucson, AZ
Hopefully, this place will go out of business. Was over charged. Not even close to the menu prices. Was charged $ 1 for a cup of water I had to fill from the tap myself. [No mention of the charge for water.] Pizza was so, so, few ingredients, and greasy. When we asked for a To-go box, I received a paper bag, and two paper plates. [paper bag almost immediately soaked in grease.] If you want a New York pizza Go somewhere else. Anywhere Else.
Eric S.
Place rating: 5 Valrico, FL
If it’s your first time coming to this place you’ll have to look for it. I pulled into Walmart area(which is next door), drove past GW and around the back. Just keep looking. It’s well worth it. I got here on a Saturday around 3:45PM and it wasn’t too busy. Just me and the food came quickly. By around 4:10, people starting rolling in though. Salad was crunchy and fresh, the bread was a little different than what I’m used to(that’s a positive thing), and OMG that lasagna! Soo much cheese and meat. If I weren’t so full right now, I’d get a pizza by the slice. I usually don’t get pizza that’s been made earlier, but these look really good — even after eating that lasagna. I’m coming here next time I want to have pizza. That is if my order doesn’t get derailed by sudden thoughts of that lasagna. Twelve and change is crazy reasonable for what I got. Usually it’s about 20 at other places.
Lonnie L.
Place rating: 5 Tampa, FL
«Best Pizza In Tampa Bay» By far, the best pizzeria within the Tampa Bay Area. Why? Because of the quality and quantity of the ingredients, the homemade red sauce and the ooooey, gooooey mozzarella. And, if that weren’t enough to bring you in, the customer service is spot on. The guys in this restaurant are as a authentic as their pies.
Megan C.
Place rating: 5 Seffner, FL
Best pie in town. Totally satisfied my craving for NY/NJ style pizza but they get a crazy busy dinner rush, so order ahead if you’re going to dine in. WORTH. THE. WAIT.
Deborah M.
Place rating: 5 Tampa, FL
Delicious authentic NY style pizza! We had the Italiana pizza — spinach, tomato, garlic with ricotta and mozzarella. Just the right amount of dough. I’ll be back to try something else if I can forego the white pizza.
Sandra J.
Place rating: 5 Silver Spring, MD
Most definitely great pizza! I was looking for N.Y. or N.J. style pizza and this os the real deal. Now I will try some entrees.
Jessica T.
Place rating: 5 Brandon, Tampa Bay, FL
For Brandon, FL they do a pretty good job of authentic Jersey style pizza… has a way to go before NY style but the flavors are there!
Leo P.
Place rating: 5 Valrico, FL
Best pizza in town. I’m from Washington Heights and this the only place in town that serves the closest thing to an authentic NY pizza. Service is great and the place is always clean. Real great restaurant.
Kim R.
Place rating: 4 Valrico, FL
We order from here through Mobile Meals at least once a month. I really love their caprese salad and to be honest have never had anything I didnt like. Their pasta sauce isn’t something I’m used to, but it’s different… a good different.
Shakyra G.
Place rating: 4 Riverview, FL
Coming from NY it’s hard to find good pizza. This place hits the spot when I’m crazing that up north taste. When I don’t feel like driving downtown, this is definitely my first choice. They are located in Brandon so it’s not too far from home… I recommend you give them a try.
Jamie W.
Place rating: 4 Valrico, FL
This is what my first time coming here to Pomodoro’s Pizza here in the Brandon/Valrico area after hearing it from my hair stylist Jasmine at Synergy Salon. I have to admit the Pepperoni and Cheese pizza is very delicious and yummy. You can watch the guys at Pomodoro Pizza make the your choice. They also have subs, pasta and some other things and accourse soft drinks, sodas and sweet tea and other delicious teas. They offer indoor and outdoor seating areas for the customer. The pizza comes in many different sizes even square for the cheese pizzas which was really squared lol. This Pizza defiantly taste like that New York pizza you never tasted before you never had from any where else. Like what others have already said if you want the best Pizza that has a real taste of Pizza go to Pomodoro’s Pizza you can’t go wrong with the prices and you will get your money’s worth!