Brooklyn Bagel Boys

I have such mixed feelings about this place. I use to come here all the time when I was younger with a bunch of friends. I think we were here every weekend and there were always about 10 of us. The owners were practically our friends. Then they got new owners and everything went to shit. If you got food to go there was a 90% chance they messed up your order. The owner was rude and very annoying. After they messed up my order 3 times in a row I stopped coming here for about a year, until I had a sandwich craving late the other night. Seems like they renovated and are under new management yet again. Unfortunately the later you come here the less bread options you have. I was craving a chicken cutlet sandwich on a roll but they had no rolls or heros so got it on a bagel. The bagels are nothing special, would’ve appreciated that roll. Overall the service was quick, friendly, and the sandwich was good.

I usually go here on the weekends. Get bagels in the morning and sandwiches late at night and their food/​service is amazing. I would give it 5 stars but once a blue moon, once every couple of months, I go at night in the middle of the week when it’s slow and they alwaayyysssss mess up my order! I ordered the chicken primavera and they gave me the chicken surprise. No pun intended! I also got half a lb of potato salad and the potatoes aren’t even cooked!!! I put up the video of my trying to cut it in half with the plastic fork and the fork was bending. So the 1 star is only for the weekday evenings lol but the weekend service is 5 stars. Their bagels are phenomenal!

Horrible. I have placed an order for a everything bagel with tomato and fresh lox. When I asked how much it would be the woman who took my order said she would have to call me back for that information. When I received my order it was just a disappointment. Has to be the worst lox bagel I have ever eaten.
Update when I called to say I wasn’t satisfied with my order I was immediately refunded my money. Costumer service is good.

This place should be marked as the iconic NY bagel, because it represents everything a bagel should be. Hot, fresh, and perfect combination of crispiness and softness. They make the bagels on premise, and if you order a bagel after they’re just made, then you have just entered bagel heaven. I ordered the primavera on numerous occasions and it has yet to disappoint. All the ingredients they use are always super fresh. The primavera has chicken, fresh mozzarella, pesto, and tomato. They are also open all the time for those late night cravings or post night out dine ins.

I’ve orders from this place probably few dozen times in the past 10 years. Unfortunately their quality and consistency seem to have gotten worse lately.
Last 2 times the salads were nothing but disappointment — egg salad that tasted like some kind of bland yellow sour-​ish paste with almost no flavor, badly over-​salted whitefish salad, chicken salad that was starting to go bad (never mind that everything is slowly becoming more expensive).
You might still be able to get fresh bagel with lox in the morning and it might be good but the fact that they lost their consistency is a big turn off.

Beautiful place. Always neat and clean. I love to go there. Very nice staff and the main thing is DELICIOUS FOOD.

There’s so much variety in the place and it’s my go-​to for a healthy meal outside. I adjust my diet accordingly to my goals in the gym and this place helps me keep up with my macros when I’m on the run and didn’t have time to pack a meal from home. The service is also great, the cold cuts as well as all other meats are really fresh, and they have tons of alternatives for things (low carb bagels, low fat tuna, sugar free desserts, etc). Best part is it’s 24 hrs :)

Food is good but the overnight crew gets my order wrong a lot. Plain tuna on a plain bagel shouldn’t be too hard to get right.

Horrible delivery service randomly decide who to deliver to and who not to.

Good bagels, fresh lox. Quick service. Wish they had cardboard coffee sleeves but now I’m just being picky.

Top notch bagels and great spreads open ²⁴⁄₇. Best bagels, cordial staff. Perfect ratio of warm doughyness to crisp.

Great fresh lox with perfect everything thin bagel without BS delivery comments like competition.
Keep up great work.

Everytime I get bagels from this place they happen to be stale or undercooked. I remember this place a couple of years back, well run and good tasty bagels. Not anymore

Fresh bagels at great prices. They arent cheap on their cream cheese. Been going here for years.

convenient to coney Island hospital and one of the better bagel options. Good cream cheese, large variety. I also like their sandwiches. The turkey with teriyaki and avocados is my favorite. Staff is nice enough and it’s always busy there. At the end of the day it’s only average at best but it’s the better option given the location.

Had terrible food poisoning after having a chicken salad sandwich. AVOID!!! BE WARE!

This afternoon I walked into Bagel Boys both to try a bagel and to escape the 90* heat at the bus stop in front of the store. At first I was impressed with how clean the place looked but when I got to the far end of the store where the bagels are sold, things went downhill fast.
I was the only customer but the guy behind the counter chose to finish talking to his friend before acknowledging me. I tried to be friendly but could only elicit monosyllabic answers. A large bagel is $ 1.00. A mini bagel that is less than half the size of a large is .80. Therefore I ordered a large everything bagel.
The sign outside the store advertises hand rolled bagels but what I received tasted more like a push cart bagel. It was hard (perhaps a day old?) and had a very skimpy coating of spices.
I then asked for a menu and the man behind the counter, acting as if he was doing me a huge favor, pointed to where they were.
The prices on the menu look reasonable but I don’t plan to do this guy a favor and visit again anytime soon.
Oh by the way I missed my bus and ended up waiting outside in the heat anyways!

If I could I would give it NO STARS! Do not support this place.
Let me start by saying, I’ve been coming here for years, but recently the management changed. The service and prices went up and food is not good anymore.
Yesterday, the new owner took my order and half way into my order he walked away from me. I expressed myself and said, don’t walk from me mid-​order. He shrugged.
The bagels are old and stale now, not good, and despite some minor renovations, all the service people have left, and this place is only here to make money. There is no longer the neighborhood feel.
Don’t go here. There are other bagels places around that are way better, and serve you with a smile.
BTW he charged me 10 bucks for a tuna on everything bagel and a large coffee. This is robbery.
This is a BIG NO-​GO!

Awesome

The bagel boys are reliable, tasty, carb-​o-​loaded treats and great for grabbing breakfast on your way to work or the express bus to Manhattan. NOT KOSHER — they serve shrimp and bacon.
DD loves the Poppy Seed bagels (loaded with fresh — dried but not dessicated — blue poppyseeds) with plain CC. I go for the Egg or Wheat bagels with lite veggiee CC and tomato.
YUM.