The Sicilian

I’ve stopped into the Sicilian twice a week since May because of my work schedule and every time I have been there it’s been great. Of course sometimes it’s a little busy and it isn’t as quick as you would like it to be but it’s definitely worth it I try something new every time I go and I’m never disappointed, I’ll always give credit to a place when it’s well deserved!

It’s pretty rare that purchasing pizza makes me mad. Somehow you guys did it. I got two margarita slices and I was charged 8 dollars and change. It was late and I was hungry so I didn’t really think about it until I got back home with my very mediocre pizza. «Wait…» I said to myself. «This isn’t half a pizza!» «Hold on!» I exclaimed. «This isn’t even good!» I had lived my whole life with no regrets up until this moment. Now I have to rewrite my whole speech to my future grandchildren. Thanks a lot The Sicilian

The staff here are so kind and will go out of their way to help you. It’s a family place. Now don’t get me wrong I’ve had better Italian food, but overall it’s a pleasant clean environment. The marinara slice is to die for. And their other slices are decent, a little bit pricey but you get what you pay for being that this is park slope were talking about. Real nice place haven’t tried their pastas or sandwiches so I can’t speak on that.

The food is either flavorless or extremely salty and every time I order in the evening everything is stale as if it was made in the early morning. Also, they must be struggling — as the last time i picked up a chicken roll i asked for a cup of sauce after i had already paid on my debit card, they literally told me no because it was 50 cents extra LOL. Last time i will ever order from this place again.

Pizza was pretty good, I had a checca slice and a plain cheese slice. The tomato sauce was very good, the dough was decent (albeit a bit oily) and the cheese was also of good quality. The downside was the price. One of the slices (a medium sized square slice was $ 5.50) which is exorbitant for a slice with no expensive meats or ingredients on it.

Horrible, hanging out at the bar down the block and decided to get a couple of pies. Don’t make the same mistake…

Usually order from this place when frequent Farrell’s. Usually the chicken roles are OK, but liked the Marsala pizza. Then one time I thought I had food poisoning and said it was a coincidence. Then tonight, since Enzo’s was closed, we got the same pie and the buffalo pizza. First waaaay too much chicken where you can’t even hold it. Next it’s like «soup thrown on baked flat bread mixed with chunks of chicken.» Next time I’m getting sushi across the street and say our prayers.

The individual slices are light years better than the pies for some reason. Why is that?

This is probably one of my favorites pizza places in Brooklyn. The staff is always friendly and the pizza is Fucking delicious !!! Honestly would recommend this to all my Floridian friend that visit Brooklyn for the first time ! A true Brooklyn staple !

Update: Went yesterday for a quick bite. Food was good; staff was nice and friendly.

This place lacks hygienic food handling. On two occasions the old guy behind the counter has grossed me out. The first time he took a topping that had fallen onto the counter and with his visibly soiled and greasy fingers threw it back on a pizza pie. On another occasion, when preparing the box for takeout, he licked his fingers and then proceeded to place the piece of wax paper into the box on which my pizza would sit. I walked out at that point. It was awful. Not to mention they all have attitudes behind the counter. I am done with this place and will never return.

I like the food and the guys are really nice but ion more than one occasion they told me 45 minutes for delivery that turns into an hour and a half and every time I call about it they say the guy «just left»

Was in Brooklyn for a business meeting came across the Sicilian and stopped in to get lunch pizza was very good, tasted like all fresh ingredients I was very pleased the only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is cause i was kind of pressed for time and it was busy so it took longer then usual to receive my pizza! I have to say. The owner is a beefcake! Let me tell you if I wasn’t already with my «Life Partner» I would order the owner Tommy for lunch!

These guys take care of you! We threw a birthday party for my son here about a month ago with 25 kids from his middle school and the staff made sure we had all the space we need out back, and that the pizzas kept coming in hot. There were also very accommodating for the adults and with the cake we brought in.
The pizza? Solid! Good, hot, and cheesy. These guys know how to bake a pie.

I am glad to say i am really Sicilian and in Sicily we DO NOT serve such crap … Better change name since the food is from bad to really bad …

We arrived after a walk through central park in the morning.
We ordered pizza by the slice. I liked the sauce on the pizza, it was flavorful.
Garlic twists were delicious as well.
I had a chance to taste a chicken sandwich with fresh bread. It was tasty as well.
Staff were friendly and quickly fixed one issue.
It was fun hearing Italian and Spanish being used in the kitchen.
They have several varieties of pizza on display.
The downside, one which I did not say to others with me, I saw a small mouse running around around a soda machine.
They also sell fresh ice cream/​gelato although we did not order any.

Looks better than it taste. The crust was crispy at first, but got soggy fast. Orders the eggplant slice and margarita. Came out to $ 9. Can get a little rowdy when kids get off school. Nice large bathroom in the back. Most likely would not come back

The Pizza is amazing here! All the food is good BUT their wait time is unreal. Sometimes I think they have actually forgotten about your order. Called in an order at 845. Called back at 10pm and they guy exclaimed «OH YEAH», they said it would be delivered in 10minutes, and 45minutes later still nothing. Keep that in mind if you’re really hungry. They take FOREVER!

This place stinks. The older guy behind the counter is argumentative and weird. The food certainly isn’t anything special. I’ve been 3 times in a year and a half– tonight was definitely the last.
Go on in if you’re into terrible service and mediocre food.

My family swears by their pizza (they always come for take out). They claim that the pizza is better when you purchase the pizza by the slice (in my opinion, usually the case). My family and I ordered in for a movie night. We ordered an eggplant roll, Sicilian pie, and shrimp Parmesan hero.
The eggplant roll was DELICIOUS! Not to mention, it was twice the size I thought it would be. The pie was good but the crust was far too hard and barely any cheese (not sure if it’s always like this?). I scraped the roof of my mouth. The shrimp Parmesan hero tasted fresh. The price came to $ 38 (not bad I must say). I will most likely give the pizza another try. The gentleman on the phone was understanding, patient, and willing to answer any questions I had (plus).