Good bagel. Had the mini everything with veggie cream cheese. the spread wasn’t that flavorful but I liked the idea of a mini. Fewer carbs and cals.
Jerett G.
Place rating: 4 Woodmere, NY
I feel like the Bagelry gets a bad wrap. I find the bagels when they are fresh delicious. They make multiple batches throughout the morning so your chances are quite high that you will get one straight out of the oven. The prices are not that bad, but they only accept cash. I even enjoy their coffee from time to time.
Nadia H.
Place rating: 3 Woodmere, NY
neighborhood bagel shop– it’s pretty hit or miss with the consistency; you have to get here early for their bagels to be fresh. If you come anytime around 11:30/noon you run the chance of a hard, stale bagel. Their service is always friendly. There egg salad, tuna, and scallion cream cheese are very good. Overall, it’s a good place– they just need to work on consistency with the bagels. Granted, it seems like common sense that they’d be fresh in the early mornings, but if you’re opened up until a certain time, ideally the bagels should be fresh up until that point