Pandora’s Pies

Great place to get very good food! these guys know how to make a calzone and do it in an efficient manner. Well worth it to stop by and give them a try!

Great food. A small pizza is big enough to split between 2 or 3. Staff is all Elon students so that could improve but never had an issue. Food is quick and good. Prices are a little higher but worth it.

An incident this evening let me know that Alamance County is still a ways away from living in to its idea of racial reconciliation. Today, as I was waiting to meet a student at Elon to discuss plans for the FBC Student Ministries, I was ignored for an hour (yes, one-​whole-​hour, 60 minutes) by the staff of Pandora’s Pies on Williamson Avenue. Granted, I did miss the sign that stated «Wait to Be Seated», but no one approached me or the student period until they wanted us to leave in order to make room for other patrons. I could’ve been asked to wait, redirected to the sign, or plainly told «we don’t serve you here». Regardless, my issue is that for an hour we both watched the tables around us be served, asked if they needed anything, while no one came to our table until they wanted us to leave. I was stared down from the moment I entered in so it was not because I went unnoticed. I wasn’t going to purchase anything but even if I had, thankfully Iola instilled in me to not buy where you are not welcome.
#ALongWayToGo

Tuesday nights are dollar slice nights! Delicious, fresh ingredients.

Just reaching the 4 star mark. Food is decently good, especially compared to other options in the area, but nothing I would run bragging about. Service tends to be super slow so don’t come in a rush. Pizza is among the best in the area.

Huh. Having read the reviews, I am perplexed as to what happened to us. Service was very slow, even tho’ the place was practically empty. Most of the stuff we ate was weirdly way too spicy. Okay, so the «spicy corn salad» you would expect to be spicy — fair enough. But why cover a «mixed green salad» in sriracha sauce ?!
Also –side note: this is the first time I have never seen corn salad made with a mayonnaise base. Not so tasty.
The tomato soup was great though.

Awesome food!!! Love the Buffalo chicken pizza and the CBR!!! Good beer selection and love the garlic knots!!!

Very happy with the food here. It’s a little on the expensive side, but then again… there’s a reason why you’re branching out from pizza hut. Personally, I think the extra dollar is worth with it for some better ingredients and to support a local business.
They have ice cream that they make there which taste good but, is very expensive. Like $ 6 and change for a pint (Ben & Jerrys is $ 3 – 4).
Here’s the thing: they can charge whatever they want for pizza because nobody in town can do it as well as they can! I’m a bit of a food snob and I won’t eat pizza anywhere else in town because every other place is garbage compared to pandoras.

We had the hankering for some pizza, so tried this place while in the area. We were not disappointed. My dining partner and I shared a small Bourbon Buffalo Chicken pizza. I wasn’t sure it was something I’d like, but I was persuaded to give it a try. It was delicious, but had a bit more BBQ sauce than I would’ve preferred. I also ordered the small house salad, which was fresh and a good size. I’ve seen others complain about the cost, so it may be on the pricey side for the area. But, coming from the DC suburbs, I thought it was quite a bit of food for the price.

The pizza here is delicious but the bill adds up quickly. I highly recommend the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Was sad they charged us for extra ranch. Good selection of draft beer. Salads are good too. Love supporting local business!

Food is really good. I love that they use local food and appreciate the look of the restaurant. The pizza and calzones are delicious, however in my opinion, the pizza does not warm up well for another meal. Too soggy. The benches are a bit uncomfortable and the wait staff is hit or miss, we have had a very pleasant and happy young lady and then the other seemed bored and snippy. It does take awhile to get the food even when there are only a few tables seated.
I will continue to visit every now and again to try more of the menu.

Very good salads and pizza. Love the ice cream kiosk inside the restaurant.

I graduated from college about a year ago, but when I lived in Elon I would literally go to Pandora’s more days than I didn’t. Love being able to customize slices, garlic knots are awesome and the wait staff was really nice. $ 1 drafts on the last day of the month is a pretty awesome deal too.

Loved the food! Wait staff took awhile to seat us even though there were 4 of them sitting at the bar. I guess they thought we were waiting for ice cream. Absolutely loved the menu. We will be back.

The NY State of Mind with local ground sausage is my favorite pizza in the state! The last day of the month they have $ 1 drafts until they run out. Show up early and order a Mystery Brewery beer if they have one on tap.

Pretty good pizza. There are lots of toppings to choose from, so if everyone gets a slice or two they can have exactly what they want for a decent price. I really enjoyed the locally cured sopresatta I had on my slices. The beer selection is pretty good as well, and the ice cream at the end was a bonus.

The pizza is good– if you’re not sharing a pizza you’re probably better off to do a custom slice. The salads and sandwiches are good too. They have $ 2 beers and $ 1 slices on Tuesday and $ 1 drafts the last day of the month.

Cool place and the food is excellent. I had the Italian sandwich. It is served open faced and the menu says you’re gonna need a fork and knife. I expected it to be a little bigger (more meat and toppings), but otherwise it was awesome! My wife had chipotle avocado chicken sandwich. Quote: «that may have been the best sandwich I’ve had in my life!» — my wife