Attilios has been my favorite place for pizza since I moved here in 2008. The eggplant pizza is the best food I ever ate in my whole life. Their chicken Marsala is the best I’ve had anywhere except my own home. Their grilled chicken Caesar salad is a great healthy option and it’s awesome because they give you so much chicken. It is definitely my favorite restaurant ever in my whole life
Matt R.
Place rating: 5 Washington, DC
Absolutely the best pizza in the area. The crust is always the right amount of crisp and crunch. The cheese and sauce on top is absolutely delicious. Whenever I crave a pizza — or a stromboli or a hot sub — I come to Attilio’s! Highly recommend the pizza with eggplant on top.
Joe B.
Place rating: 3 Freehold, NJ
They do make a good pizza and the grandma pie is very good. Chicken parm entrée and hero are very good along with the cheese steak and meatball heroes. A little pricey for a pizza joint and they do not deliver. Have to agree with the other reviewer, the owner could use some charm lessons. Always looks like he just ate a bowl of lemons! I generally avoid conversation with him so I don’t get pissed off and ruin my meal.
Greg B.
Place rating: 1 New York, NY
I agree with Doc B. Mediocre pizza with surly service bordering on hostile. Skip this place entirely, and travel ¼ mile to Cucina Alessi Pizza right next to Wegmans for one of the best pizzas(along with great service) in NJ.
Doc B.
Place rating: 1 Freehold, NJ
Good pizza, rude staff. You decide. Not for me. Nastiness ruins the flavor. The map alongside this review is completely wrong, but you don’t need the map to know where not to go.