Pet Supplies Plus

I love PSP so much. With four pet shops in the area, this is always the first one I turn to, and has been for the past 10+ years. I cannot recall ever having a poor experience or reason to not want to come back.
First of all, it is an extremely clean and well organized store with knowledgeable and friendly employees. If I can’t find a product or just need a recommendation I can count on them to give an honest opinion instead of up-​selling a promotional product. I am always asked if I need help carrying heavy items to my car, and have had products special ordered or held for pickup at no extra charge. Service is the top priority here.
Whatever your pet, and I have run the gamut on household pets, you are bound to find what you need here for toys, food, treats and more. They carry top quality food brands as well as what I’d call mid-​range brands. Nutrition is important and they try to stock a variety of healthy options including locally made foods. There is a typical selection of dog and cat toys but the prices are very competitive here. And clothing, because who doesn’t dress up their pets?!
Quick aside; Rabbits have fragile digestive systems and I only feed particular brand of food and hay as well as offering specific toys (sadly, I am a snob on behalf of my rabbits). PSP has always been the only store to carry the brand I prefer, even though other stores are now catching on. They also offer Critical Care formula which is a life saver if you are familiar with rabbits and guinea pigs. A few years back you could only obtain this from a vet. Having it readily available is awesome.
If you sign up for email and their reward club you are in for a treat. Updates on vet clinics, tons of coupons and a free toy (up to $ 5) on your pets birthday. There is also photo contests, pictures with Santa, and community events that PSP is involved in.
I won’t lie. I’m extremely happy that no live pets are sold here. It leads me to believe that the owner and employees care enough about animals to accommodate not keeping any in the store.
Other pluses: pets are welcome, employees are quick to clean up accidents, plenty of parking, convenient hours.
Seriously, this store is the bees knees.

We buy products for both ends of our cats here.
Give them the food and out it comes into the litter we buy here.
All locations in the area have what our cats like to poop on, and at a great price also.
As long as we have critters in the house we will shop here. Unless it is a squirrel. Then we will go to Farm and Fleet for a live trap.

The best prices for Taste of the Wild in the area, I love that they sell the better quality dog foods that places like Petsmart doesn’t. Excellent selection of toys and treats too, especially for my pup that has a lot of food allergies!
I especially love that this location doesn’t sell pets of any kind.

I love love love this store. I go weekly for all my puppy and guinea pigs needs. The staff is so knowledgeable. «grandpa“was just wonderful with helping me find the best puupy food for my pup.
Thank you for making our shopping for our pets so fun and stress free.

Always friendly staff, that love, pet and feed my dog free treats. (I mean who wouldn’t though, he is honestly the best dog)
The prices are a bit better than Pets Mart and Pet Co and I like that it feels more local, I am pretty sure it is a local franchise.
Also the have FROMM pet food which I appreciate, as this is what Griffin eats and it comes straight from good ol Wisconsin. *Support the local WI businesses* :)

A no frills pet store that doesn’t sell pets.
The variety of foods, toys and whatever other supplies you may need for your home zoo is enormous.
I find the prices to be lower than other stores in the area (for the better foods, at least), and they always have some kind of sales promotion going on.
You may bring your pet in here, as long as it is in a carrier or on a leash. Not gonna lie, I had an enormous rabbit that I brought in to fit for a harness. Ended up trying on dog harnesses because the rabbit ones were way to small… glad I did that; saved me several trips! I surprised a few of the other customers, too, so that was fun! Bonus? If your pet has an accident, the staff will clean it up. Doesn’t even phase them.
Sign your pet up for the birthday club and during their birthday month, you (they) will get a coupon for a free toy.
75÷2014÷80

I’m a big fan of Pet Supplies Plus! Very well stocked and staffed, employees are very knowledgeable and helpful but not overbearing. Prices are decent and the selection is great. Plus you can bring animals in! Biggest hassle is getting into the parking lot when heading north, but it’s worth the extra effort!

I LOVE bringing my dog into this store! Everyone is so friendly and willing to help in the drop of a hat it makes going so enjoyable! Even if my dog ends up marking, someone is always happy to follow behind with a mop haha. The store is very, very clean. Bright and cheery. The prices are on the lower side when it comes to pet stores. There is a variety of selected products and if there is something you cannot find someone will find it, order it and have it brought to you if you are in desperate need of it. There are always sales going on in store. And coupons are given out frequently. I rave about this store and cannot say enough positive things about it!

Pet Supplies Plus always has a good selection of cat food for a good price — especially when I have to buy cat food that does not contain grains.
It’s in a good location although sometimes it’s a pain to get out of the parking lot to get on the freeway but that’s just a minor detail.

Easy to find location. They seem to have a pretty good selection of natural food however, I went to purchase a bag and it was expired. Great selection of toys, not sure if their treats are fresh. Weary of purchasing any food products unpackaged there since the expiration date of the bag of food I found was a few months past its date.